Comments / New

Stargazing, A Dallas Stars Puckcast – Episode 272: The Unthinkable

What’s the true cost of a superstar RHD, and are Stars fans really prepared to face it? Wes and Mark mull it over.

Defending Big D's Stargazing podcast logo, featuring a Dallas Stars Victory Green cassette tape with tearaway jersey texture and nets over the sprocket holes, designed by Jason Lara
Logo design: Jason Lara | @NHLMaps

What’s the true cost of a superstar RHD, and are Stars fans really prepared to face it? Wes and Mark mull it over.

History tells us how the Dallas Stars embarked on their fateful 1999 Stanley Cup run, and now we will, too: It was a time of magic and fantasy, brought to you by hard work and hard decisions.

Few have forgotten that the deal that brought the Stars Joe Nieuwendyk also cost them Jarome Iginla. Fewer still would take that trade back – even knowing the face-of-the-franchise, first-ballot Hall of Famer Iggy would become – considering what it ultimately brought.

With all this being true, and assuming the Stars are one player away from taking it all again in 2025…what would Stars fans consider a fair trade for the piece they’re missing?

Wes and Mark decided to address the fannish conversations about this issue, and the scenario they relate is not the one you want to hear. Reality is what it is – but there’s always the possibility you can substitute a different one. And they discuss that, too.

Magic is fun when you know the secret. Join us for a little Stargazing. It’s brought to you by BetOnline.

And if you don’t like talking hockey, but like talking business…tell us about it in the comments. We’ll discuss your ideas in a future cast. (No, really!)

One more thing: Please leave us a tip in the form of a like, review or share. It’ll be our favorite holiday gift ever. Thanks for listening!

There is nothing wrong with the Dallas Stars. Their systems work, and so does their lineup. And this Minnesota Wild team is still exactly what we thought it was. So how do we square these things with the…effort we saw in Game 1? To make sense of Saturday's loss, we needed to bring in the big guns. So Wes and Mark tackled the topic with NHL.com's Taylor Baird – whom you also know as DBD's editor-in-chief. They went over the lines that worked (and didn't), the injuries that still dog the team, and what the Stars will do to rally after getting punched in the face. The Stars have a history of losing the first game in a Stanley Cup Playoffs round, then going on to win the series. We're Stargazing, and we're taking the long view for as long as we can. What's your take on Game 1? Let us know at Defending Big D. And please don’t forget to rate, review and share wherever you listen. It's the daily affirmation that we love most of all. Welcome to Stargazing. We love you. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
  1. Round 1, Game 1 Reactions
  2. First-Round Preview: Stars vs. Wild
  3. Texas Stars Spring Update 2026
  4. Goalie Goals
  5. Dropping Lines

Talking Points