Breaking Down the Dallas Stars Back-to-Back Woes

Hannah Foslien

Poor penalty killing and a swing in save percentage have left the Stars on the wrong end on nearly all second games of back-to-backs in the Glen Gulutzan era.

Of all the demons the Dallas Stars have battled during the Glen Gulutzan tenure, perhaps the most frustrating has been the struggles on the back-end of back-to-back games.

It's no secret at this point that that Stars are 1-15-2 under Gulutzan on the second day of a back-to-back set, the most recent loss a 7-4 dispatching by the Calgary Flames on Wednesday.

But what is it about these games that the Stars struggle so mightily with? Travel has been brought up time and time again, but in the pair of home-and-home series they've had during this stretch, they've struggled just as much as they did when the other team was rested. Playing the backup goalie, be that Andrew Raycroft, Cristopher Nilstorp or most often Richard Bachman, is also a part of the problem, but Kari Lehtonen has started six games during that stretch. He hasn't fared much better than his fellow netminders, being yanked twice (once due to injury) with a 1-4-1 record.

So I decided to dig into the stats a little bit to see if I could pinpoint just what is going wrong. Mark Stepneski got me started with his handy chart of front-end and back ends of back-to-backs over the past two years, and I ran the gamesheets to pull out more statistics.

While the results aren't stunningly conclusive, they do point to two areas where the Stars are giving up goals - overall shaky goaltending (likely related to the quality of scoring chances allowed), and a problematic penalty kill.

The most clear one is the penalty kill, so let's start there. Here's a pair of tables, one for last season and one for this one, comparing the Stars special teams play in all games, back-end of back-to-backs and the remaining games in a season.


PPs drawn PP goals PP percentage PKs given PK goals allowed PK percentage
All games 244 33 13.5 303 52 82.8
All avg. per game 2.98 0.40 3.69 0.63
Back-end 32 6 18.75 53 12 77.35
Back-end avg. 2.29 .42 3.78 0.85
Remaining 212 27 12.74 250 40 84
Remaining avg. 3.12 0.40 3.68 0.59


PPs drawn PP goals PP percentage PKs given PK goals allowed PK percentage
All games 48 9 18.8 64 11 82.8
All avg. per game 3.43 0.64 4.57 0.79
Back-end 14 2 14.29 18 4 77.8
Back-end avg. 3.5 0.5 4.5 1
Remaining 34 7 20.59 46 7 84.78
Remaining avg. 2.4 0.7 4.6 0.7

The power play last year was actually more efficient on the back end of back-to-backs (though given last year's power play, that's not saying much), so I'm less inclined to give a lot of weight to the struggles this year. The more consistent problem is the dramatic dip in the PK percentage.

Despite giving up essentially the same number of penalties to kill in back-ends versus the remaining games (68 from 2011-12 and 10 from this year), the Stars penalty kill gives up about 0.20 goals against per game, and the PK percentage drops by around 7 percent. That's a huge drop, and the fact that the numbers are almost exactly the same this year versus last season makes me inclined to call it a trend.

Why would that be? Your guess is as good as mine, honestly. A good portion of it may be related to the problems with save percentage, which leads me to the next charts.

The other ridiculously dramatic statistical swing in the back-end games comes from raw goals against versus goals for, part of which is directly tied to a drop in save percentage. Here's charts detailing the swings in goals for and against, shots for and against and save percentage. The caveat on save percentage is a team statistic in this chart and therefore includes empty net goals.


Shots for Goals for Shots against Goals against Save Percentage
All games 2315 204 2527 218 .914
All avg. per game 28.2 2.49 30.8 2.66
Back-end 369 34 442 50 .887
Back-end avg. 26.35 1.71 31.75 3.57
Remaining 1946 180 2085 168 .919
Remaining avg. 28.61 2.64 30.66 2.47


Shots for Goals for Shots against Goals against Save Percentage
All games 365 33 447 36 .919
All avg. per game 26.1 2.36 31.9 2.57
Back-end 101 5 116 14 .880
Back-end avg. 25.25 1.25 29 3.5
Remaining 264 28 331 22 .933
Remaining avg. 26.4 2.8 33.1 2.2

The shot differential does have a bit of a swing to it on the back-end of back-to-backs, though this year the Stars are actually allowing fewer shots to the opposition in those games after a slight uptick in that area last year. The Stars are also taking slightly fewer shots.

But that shouldn't account for the wild swings in goals for and goals against. For some reason, the Stars simply can't seem to turn their shots into goals at the same rate in back-end games, while at the other end of the ice the opposition is feasting on a fairly similar amount of opportunities.

Some of that is obviously dependent on the quality of chances these shots represent, and I simply don't have access to those numbers at this point. It would be very interesting to know if the Stars were containing the number of shots overall but giving up significantly more prime scoring opportunities. My suspicion is that's a very significant statistical swing from their other games.

The other stark contrast here is obviously the save percentage, which as I mentioned above spans the four goalies the Stars have had up over the past two seasons. The starts break down as this - four for Raycroft, six for Lehtonen, seven for Bachman and one for Nilstorp. That is an above-average helping of backup goaltending, but not ridiculously so, and honestly, everyone has struggled.

Even when you break out the differences in goals against per period, it's about what you'd expect from teams who are getting beat handily.


Dallas 1st GF Dallas 2nd GF Dallas 3rd GF Opp 1st GF Opp 2nd GF Opp 3rd GF
All games 58 62 80 59 80 78
All avg. per game 0.71 0.76 0.98 0.72 0.98 0.95
Back-end 8 9 7 14 20 15
Back-end avg. 0.57 0.64 0.5 1 1.42 1.04
Remaining 50 53 73 45 60 63
Remaining avg. 0.73 0.78 1.07 0.66 0.88 0.92


Dallas 1st GF Dallas 2nd GF Dallas 3rd GF Opp 1st GF Opp 2nd GF Opp 3rd GF
All games 12 11 9 9 17 9
All avg. per game 0.85 0.79 0.64 0.64 1.21 0.64
Back-end 1 3 1 5 5 4
Back-end avg. .25 .75 .25 1.25 1.25 1
Remaining 11 8 8 4 16 5
Remaining avg. 1.1 0.8 0.8 0.4 1.3 0.5

I wish I had shots-by-period totals from the season to compare those, but my ability to find such things in the database failed. The data I have from just the back-end games is that the Stars are getting outshot by 1.5 on average in the first period, 3 in the second and outshooting their opponents by 1.5 in the third.

As far as brilliant solutions to the problem of back-end games, there really aren't any I can come up with. The Stars have to be better in all aspects, with a particular emphasis of bringing the penalty kill and save percentage back to the level they are in the rest of the season.

At some time, some way, that's going to happen. Right?

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Defending Big D

You must be a member of Defending Big D to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Defending Big D. You should read them.

Join Defending Big D

You must be a member of Defending Big D to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Defending Big D. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.