NHL Tradedeadline 2012
Who should the Stars target?
I can't help but think that Ruutu, the oft-injured center, is a guy that Dallas should avoid. I would prefer that if The Stars do go after a top 6 forward, that they should get someone who could provide more than secondary scoring, on a consistent level. That means- not someone who has a history of being on IR. A gritty depth forward would be a nice acquisition, and it always is nice to see guys join the roster who are "difficult to play against". One thing to consider however, is that with a plethora of depth forwards already in Dallas or Cedar Park, and several on the way from the college, European leagues and junior hockey, The Stars may not want to cramp opportunities that could be had by younger, more affordable (already contracted) forwards.
Having said that, here's a list of players I'd like to see GM Joe Nieuwendyk and Co. inquiring about:
Bobby Ryan (ANA)- unlikely, unless we pay heavily, but he's so talented and can line up at either C or wing. And, he's younger than guys like Iginla or Nash, and perhaps more versatile.
Zach Parise (NJD)- talented; his father was a North Star. Perhaps that would entice him to consider a move to Dallas.
Alexander Semin (WAS)- I'm digging here- again. But if The Stars could pry him from the grasp of the Capitals, they'd have a legitimate forward who would put fans in the stands and who could show the Stars faithful that a new day has come, and that they are going to be competive with the NHL's Elite.
Of course I wouldn't be opposed to acquiring Iginla, as Dallas could afford his contract, especially if Morrow were to go the other way. And he provides excellent leadership and is a recognizable name. Why not? That said, one of the above would be a far more exciting addition, in my eyes.
As for defense, I, like many others, would be thrilled with an addition like Weber or Suter. I always hoped we'd get Del Zotto or Staal from the Rangers for Richards, but that didn't happen. And I hoped we could make a move for Burns or Bogosian last summer. That also did not happen. Should we not be able to up the ante on defense and acquire a top defender, there are some other guys that Dallas could look at.
Keaton Ellerby (FLA)- a first round pick from a few years ago. Still young, at 24, and mammoth sized. He would be a great shutdown defender and I'm curious if Nieuwendyk has his sights on any Panthers players, given his tenure with the team as a player and in training as an executive.
Dan Girardi (NYR)- If Del Zotto or Staal couldn't be had from the Rangers last year, maybe this guy could? Doubt it, but I would love to see him in a Stars uniform. And while we're at it, how about a blockbuster deal to acquire Ansimov and Wolski? Not likely, but perhaps Wolski could become yet another successful Stars reclamation project.
Who are you guys hoping for?
This is a user-created FanPost and does not necessarily reflect the views of SB Nation or Defending Big D. FanPost opinions are valued expressions of opinion by passionate and knowledgeable hockey and Dallas Stars fans.
63 comments
|
2 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Semin the Slap fighter!
I’d rather chase someone like Malkin, he’s not entirely needed in pittsburg, they would still have crosby an staal. Only other two would be Iginla an Nash, but i dont think all that much is gonna happen to be honest.
by Chris Lca Williams on Jan 9, 2012 5:11 AM CST reply actions
I like Staal
But if Joe is set on bringing one of the Staals to the Western Conference, I would rather have Jordan. He’s one of the best two-way centers in the game and would fit perfectly in Gully’s system.
Carpe diem!
Jordan Staal is injured currently
Along with Crosby, Letang, and Neal – out for “weeks” according to reports. Pens could need to make a move for some scoring with all those guys out if they hope to maintain a playoff position this season.
by Taylor Baird on Jan 9, 2012 11:44 AM CST up reply actions
let's get that Neal guy....
He’s been pretty awesome this season.
"He punched the highlights out of her hair.... He punched the HIGHLIGHTS out of her hair!!!" -- Young Neil
Yeah Malkin or Staal would be awesome
woops accidently posted that. Pens have so many good centers. But i’d also like derek stepan, josh bailey or even brayden schenn to come on over. Him an glennie were dominate at the wheat kings. Maybe it’ll help glennie not be a total wash.
Here’s a long shot, but would anyone see Kesler leave the canucks? I like how he plays. I’d rather us pick up a top center or some young almost nhl ready young guys to play with our young team. Just my 2 cents
by Chris Lca Williams on Jan 15, 2012 11:31 PM CST up reply actions
Doubtful on Kesler
didn’t they just sign him to a long term deal?
by Travis Drybread on Jan 17, 2012 11:27 AM CST up reply actions
Theres no reason for Kesler or Malkin to be available.
Defending Big D Check it out
Twitter
"You guys are talking about living forever like it’s a real thing, but I bust out a man shoving his head into a vagina, and it’s srs time?"
--iorange555 8/23/2011
Ruutu is okay.
He fits well in system of Gulutzan, but yes… Injuries are the problem with him.
Trevor Daley is my cup of tea.
NOT SEMIN!
He’s the very definition of a soft player. There are tons of questions about his work ethic, and much like Ovechkin – he cannot play defense worth a crap. He has world class skill – but too often he is content to mail it in.
Carpe diem!
Unfortunately, I don't think we're deep enough in prospects to compete in trades for any of the players that would really fit in well.
The only way it would work is if the player has a NTC, and lists only a few teams that he’s willing to go to. I don’t want to sacrifice our future for another rental player. I’d rather wait to see what comes about in free agency.
"He punched the highlights out of her hair.... He punched the HIGHLIGHTS out of her hair!!!" -- Young Neil
Don't know much
about Ruutu’s injury history, but looking at his career stats only two seasons has he not played at least 70 games, and has played 82 twice, including last season, and don’t think he’s missed any this year. He’s a guy I’ved looked at at least in free agency as someone realistic to acquire, think he can play C or W, gritty and can score 20-25 goals. on pace for over 25 this season.
by StarzenheimerSchmidt on Jan 9, 2012 11:09 AM CST reply actions
Shuffle back to Buffalo
We got a pretty good player the last time we took a center from the Sabres…might be a good fit to grab another one. I like Derek Roy’s game, he is a career +42 but is a minus this year. He had a short year last season (concussion???) but has played all games this season.
Some people live an entire lifetime wondering if they have made a difference, Marines don't have that problem - Ronald Reagan
Think I saw
Sabres put him on the block. I like him, but it’s not even a conversation unless the Stars would rather have Roy at C and Benn at wing, unless they actually try to trade Ribs. I’d actually like more of a goal scoring threat centering the third line as well, but that’s overkill. And I do really like Fiddler but on a championship team he’s probably on the fourth line.
by StarzenheimerSchmidt on Jan 9, 2012 12:34 PM CST up reply actions
I like your thinking...
I noticed that Brassard and Vermette may be available. Vermette is a good faceoff man who may have a higher ceiling than Fiddler, though he’s certainly not showing it this year (this could be in large part due to the team he’s with). If we could somehow, someway, swindle Brassard from Scott Howson’s Blue Jackets, we’d be getting a center who could perhaps one day be our number 1 guy. At least until someone better came along.
Realistically, unless we’re willing to give up something significant, like an Eriksson or Benn (no thanks), we’re not going to receive a top guy via a trade very easily. We’re more likely looking at a reclamation project, prospects, someone with a bad contract, etc. It sucks, but these are the times where I just hope that there’s a taker out there like there was in 2008 when we acquired Brad Richards.
Even if we’re offering up a combination of Morrow, Robidas, Daley, Grossman, prospects and picks, I don’t think we can expect the Webers or Nashes of the world to join us unless we’re overpaying or if we have something they’re really wanting. Maybe someone values Glennie as a top prospect; Morrow as an aging, yet valuable winger with experience and leadership qualities; and a defenseman like Daley, Grossman, Robidas, or even Fistric as being someone who they could use as a top 4 defenseman (if they saw things that way). They may likely ask for a pick and another prospect, as well as a younger roster player like a Wandell or Larsen in return.
We shouldn’t expect to get something for nothing. But thinning out our cupboards to make way for newer players in our minor league teams and giving younger players the chance to succeed by creating the space for them might pay off in dividends as well. Maybe we’ll lose a guy like Larsen, Vincour or Glennie that could turn into something special. I hope not (except for Glennie, as I’m losing faith in him), but the return could be well worth it if it improves the on-ice product.
Dan Girardi isn't going anywhere.
Whatever they do depends on their lineup going forward.
If they stick with Eriksson/Ribeiro/Morrow then they need to focus on finding a LW or C for the Benn/Ryder duo. I don’t think its reasonable to expect them to find that long term fit at the deadline this year, but who knows. A very good short term fit (and potentially longer term fit until you find that guy) is Jussi Jokinen. He’s a solid to very good possession guy, he has a history of generating offense, and he can play decent defense for you.
Defending Big D Check it out
Twitter
"You guys are talking about living forever like it’s a real thing, but I bust out a man shoving his head into a vagina, and it’s srs time?"
--iorange555 8/23/2011
Keep the young guns and sign Shane Doan as UFA
I think they should keep what they have up front and sign Doan as a UFA this summer. I think Gaglardi and Doan have a connection or two that couldn’t hurt negotiations.
Either that or deal for some physical D men that can help out the goal diff. improve.
we are deep with depth forwards and D men
so were going to most likely cut a deal with a team in need of depth and defense. there a few teams that fit the description and as teams fall further out of playoff contention the number of teams will increase.
we can also take on a short term cap dump from a higher salary team.
my brain begins to hurt when i try to predict a deal, but the deadline should get interesting
How is Parise on faceoffs?
Does anyone know? Do you guys all feel confident in Benn as a no. 1 center?
I think he can get there. He's talented enough.
Eriksson – Benn – Parise
Morrow – Ribeiro – Ryder
that’s a swell top 6.
by Travis Drybread on Jan 10, 2012 8:58 PM CST up reply actions
I don't know about Morrow...
I could actually see us moving him, either in a pkg deal to acquire a forward to replace him, or to just let a guy like Wandell, or eventually- Vincour replace him and wait until next season. Then- maybe a free agent or a rookie could step in, if they’re ready.
I feel like a year ago, a 31 year old Morrow would yield us a top 6 forward in the 4-5 million price range. Maybe a guy like a Versteeg or something like that, not an elite winger obviously. But now- we’re lucky if other teams view Morrow as worth 3 million in contract- or less.
I know people have mentioned Jussi Jokinen, and I wouldn’t mind that, but what about Olli Jokinen from Calgary? I’ve never been his biggest fan, but the price is right, the age is ok, and he’s a big center. At best, he could be a 65-70 point forward. We’re not pressuring him like he was in Calgary, Long Island, LA or Florida to be THE MAN. We’d just need him to be a secondary guy. Why not?
Morrow has a NTC, as does Ribs. Loui and Benn are the future. Ott is too valuable to this club, and not valuable enough to others.
And we just signed Ryder, so trading him would hurt us when we try to sign FAs. That leaves the bottom 6 to trade (which aren’t worth much), and picks to sacrifice our future.
"He punched the highlights out of her hair.... He punched the HIGHLIGHTS out of her hair!!!" -- Young Neil
Ya, I don't think any of those four can or will be traded.
Morrow is the Captain, Ribs is our best “actual” center, Ott is a great all around kind of player (wins faceoffs, hits, fights, can score, irritates), and like you said, Ryder just got here and dumping him somewhere would look bad.
If we trade anyone it’s going to be someone like Wandell, Bachman, or prospects. I don’t think we’ll drop any picks unless we’re getting some (preferably 1st rd or 5th rd) in return. It’ll be a tall order for Joe to land a Parise/Nash/Weberesque caliber player, but I truly hope that he can and does.
by Travis Drybread on Jan 12, 2012 6:53 PM CST up reply actions
I’ll say this much, there is a 0% chance, if not somehow lower, that the Rangers trade Dan Girardi this season. Staal is just coming back, Sauer is not healthy, and if anything the Rangers will be looking for defense.
Anisimov almost definitely cannot be acquired, but Wolski probably can be.
Follow me on twitter @nyybrandonc
Co-Manager/Writer for Pinstripe Alley, Editor/Writer for Blueshirt Banter
"No matter what I talk about, I always get back to baseball."
"Every day is a great day for hockey."
Kyle Okposso
dont know if we have any chance in getting him or if he is even available but he would be a perfect fit on this team
Here were the scenarios I presented in another thread
Grossman/Fistric, Bachman, 2nd round pick for Parise
Larsen, Vincour, and a 1st round pick for Weber
I know that this might not be enough/be too much for these two guys, but we’ve got to start speculation somewhere. I don’t think it hurts our future too much if we can get assurance that we sign those two for 5 or 6 years in the process.
If a deal is struck between the GMs that is contingent on Parise/Weber signing in Dallas long term, Joe will be able to talk to those guys and get it worked out. I hope he does it. Stars need a HUGE splash to be made after this Benn/Ribeiro news.
by Travis Drybread on Jan 15, 2012 6:00 PM CST reply actions
Vincour
I really feel that Vincour is going to be a surprise talent for us. I’d much rather move someone like Reilly Smith or Scott Glennie…
Either way. I don't mind either of them going either.
I just want the speculation to begin.
by Travis Drybread on Jan 15, 2012 6:13 PM CST up reply actions
There is some really good trade talk in this thread
It’s over 230 comments, I don’t think I can copy and paste all of it
Not sure if you guys have seen this yet
But In Lou We Trust just posted about what they would take for Parise. I say Glennie, Grossman, and a 1st for Parise and maybe a lower pick depending on how we’re doing in the standings at the time of the deal.
"If the laws of physics no longer apply in the future, God help you."
as long as that lower pick isn't a 5th and NJ would do it.
I’d be saying later to Grossman and Glennie.
by Travis Drybread on Jan 17, 2012 4:38 PM CST up reply actions
Personally, I feel like if Joe is going to have any chance of swiping Parise
he’s gotta start talking to NJ asap. Get in their ear long before the masses start calling.
by Travis Drybread on Jan 17, 2012 4:43 PM CST up reply actions
Although I think we could get him for that offer
I feel like it may be overpaying. The only way we do this is if there is a way to guarantee he signs here long term.
Honestly, I think it's a fair deal.
We know what Grossman is, Glennie is still a guessing game, and a 1st round pick is a toss up.
I’ll take the certainty of Parise’s production over that.
by Travis Drybread on Jan 18, 2012 10:19 AM CST up reply actions
I'll go with Grossman and a first.
I’m stingy.
"He punched the highlights out of her hair.... He punched the HIGHLIGHTS out of her hair!!!" -- Young Neil
I don't know
just because it doesn’t even guarantee us a playoff spot and probably at least 50/50 he doesn’t re-sign with us. Which means we could lose all that and get nothing whatsoever for it(Parise for a couple months and no playoffs). Big risk for a GM to take. If I knew there was a really good chance he’d re-sign then definitely worth it.
Suter has to be a much higher priority though. Like I’ve said before, I can’t envision any other reasonable scenario that the Stars find a #1 defenseman now or in FA. Something they aren’t close to having on the roster. They have All-Star caliber forwards already.
by StarzenheimerSchmidt on Jan 18, 2012 11:12 AM CST up reply actions
Sign and trade then?
If Joe and Lou can come to an agreement, Joe can then throw out the stipulation that he can talk to Parise ahead of time to agree on a contract. If Parise approves, the deal is doe, if not, Lou can appease those rabid Maple Leaf fans. The entire point of the deal is to build for the future, so hopefully, Joe would get to talk to Zach before the deal was done.
"If the laws of physics no longer apply in the future, God help you."
by Virginian Star on Jan 18, 2012 11:37 AM CST up reply actions
I was wondering this earlier.
Can we do it that way? That would make the deal a definite all go for me.
It’d let us get in before the “bidding wars” of free agency and the trade deadline. He’s going to cost a lot either way, and he deserves to make the money based on his skill, but it’d be nice to not have to bid for his services against the teams that will overpay .
by Travis Drybread on Jan 18, 2012 12:12 PM CST up reply actions
I'm pretty sure it goes against the CBA.
Plus, that would require NJ extending parise, and then why would they want to trade him after that?
"He punched the highlights out of her hair.... He punched the HIGHLIGHTS out of her hair!!!" -- Young Neil
Well that's unfortunate.
I just want him in Dallas. Somehow. For more than 2 months.
I have faith that Joe can make it happen. Just not sure if Parise is even someone he’s looking at.
by Travis Drybread on Jan 18, 2012 12:19 PM CST up reply actions
Yeah,
just doesn’t happen in the NHL :-/ unlike the NBA I think they do it a lot.
by StarzenheimerSchmidt on Jan 18, 2012 12:21 PM CST up reply actions
Personally I like Weber better than Suter
I think Weber is the best defenceman in the league. Maybe chara but I still think weber is better than him. Plus didnt Suter sign an extension earlier this year at the same time as Rinne?
Weber is the kind of guy we need. The guy we havent had since Derian Hatcher. If you put goligoski and weber together thatd be a great pairing right there. Another guy id look at if we cant get parise would be derek roy. Speedy centre with solid playmaking abilities and still relatively young.
No, Suter has not signed one. There's only been rumors of negotiations.
Weber is going to be far more expensive than Suter, since he is a RFA, and the Preds will retain his rights.
"He punched the highlights out of her hair.... He punched the HIGHLIGHTS out of her hair!!!" -- Young Neil
We dont need to go the cheaper route
Weber is the way to go…enough said
The only way the Stars land Weber is through a huge trade
There is no way the Stars put an offer sheet up for him. Doing that would dive Nashville our next 3-5 (somewhere in there) 1st round picks.
It’s much more plausible that they go after Suter.
No way
not worth it, you’d give away way too much to be worth having any player.
by StarzenheimerSchmidt on Jan 18, 2012 12:40 PM CST up reply actions
exaclty.
Having that #1 guy is great.
But not at the expense of half your future. One player does not a team make.
"He punched the highlights out of her hair.... He punched the HIGHLIGHTS out of her hair!!!" -- Young Neil
Just as the Devils, who have Kovalchuk, Parise, and.......
and……. ummmmm….uhhhhh…..
"He punched the highlights out of her hair.... He punched the HIGHLIGHTS out of her hair!!!" -- Young Neil
Thats the point of a deep system
we have enough pieces where picks and prospects can be included in deals but dont have to sell the farm. Oleksiak and campbell wont be going anywhere but there are plenty of forwards out there that stocks are rising for.
You'll sell the farm
to acquire any elite RFA player. Is any player worth losing like 5 straight years of first round picks if you sign them to an offer sheet? Nashville knows that, so if you trade his rights, they know they can ask for way more than he’s worth because if they don’t trade him and a team wants him, Nashville gets all those picks for years to come to build their own future.
by StarzenheimerSchmidt on Jan 18, 2012 1:10 PM CST up reply actions
The Devils aren't going to do that....
And the Stars shouldn’t either.
The Devils aren’t going to value a goal scoring forward that isn’t scoring goals. They play a defensive system. I don’t see how Glennie fits, and I don’t think he has any value.
Grossman is a soon to be UFA bottom pairing/PK defenseman. I don’t think either of the player pieces are worth anything.
I don’t think it’s wise for the Stars to risk dealing a potential top 10 pick for a UFA forward. it doesn’t make any sense.
Defending Big D Check it out
Twitter
"You guys are talking about living forever like it’s a real thing, but I bust out a man shoving his head into a vagina, and it’s srs time?"
--iorange555 8/23/2011
worth anything to NJ for Parise*
Defending Big D Check it out
Twitter
"You guys are talking about living forever like it’s a real thing, but I bust out a man shoving his head into a vagina, and it’s srs time?"
--iorange555 8/23/2011
I agree with the first round comment
I wouldn’t mind throwing them a 2nd, Grossman and possibly Vincour (he fits a lot more into the NJ system than Glennie).
Neither team should do that either.
That isn’t enough of a return for a player of Parise’s caliber given the areas Vincour still needs to work on and the fact that Grossman isn’t going to be worth much to NJ. He’s a UFA bottom pairing defender. That deal is basically the equivalent of a 2nd, 3rd, and Vincour for Parise.
The Stars don’t need to be moving players like Vincour either. He’s exactly the type of player the Stars need going forward. He just needs to develop his offensive game more by working on getting into open ice offensively on a more consistent basis. When/if he does that he’s going to be a force.
Defending Big D Check it out
Twitter
"You guys are talking about living forever like it’s a real thing, but I bust out a man shoving his head into a vagina, and it’s srs time?"
--iorange555 8/23/2011
Exactly.
No matter what people discuss, the trades for big names just doesn’t fit the Stars right now.
"He punched the highlights out of her hair.... He punched the HIGHLIGHTS out of her hair!!!" -- Young Neil
Right
and a lot of these proposals are crazy. You have to pretend you’re a fan of the other team and they are the Stars. Why would they want to get garbage and give you gold?
by StarzenheimerSchmidt on Jan 18, 2012 12:23 PM CST up reply actions
And for the last time....
NOBODY FREAKING WANTS GLENNIE.
He is not an acceptable piece of trade bait. Just because we got him in the first round doesn’t make him worth anything to any other organization.
"He punched the highlights out of her hair.... He punched the HIGHLIGHTS out of her hair!!!" -- Young Neil
I disagree
with you slightly on that statement. Angelo Esposito was the corner stone of the Marian Hossa trade, and he was a late first rounder.
Something Clever.

by 


























