Stars Collapse In Second Period, Lose Fifth Straight
It took just 61 seconds for the Dallas Stars to completely crumble against the Minnesota Wild.
The teams had been playing relatively even hockey to the midway point of the second period with the Stars and had just taken a 2-1 lead when Philip Larsen snuck a shot through an Adam Burish screen.
Then the wheels, along with the ball bearings, axles and probably the transmission as well, came off as the Stars gave up three stunning defensive breakdown goals over a span of 61 seconds.
Cal Clutterbuck tied the game two and a half minutes after Larsen's first NHL goal, then Chad Rau used a solid helping of Brenden Morrow's stick to score his first career goal 14 seconds later. Kyle Brodziak wrapped up the carnage after the Wild went cross ice twice and pulled several players completely out of position to cap off what would be the defining stretch of this game and maybe this portion of the schedule.
A goalie change didn't make much of a difference as the Stars got caught pressing early in the third period and Dany Heatley beat Richard Bachman on a 2-on-1. But the story of the game was already written by that point.
The funny thing is, until the collapse, the Stars had done basically what they wanted in terms of dictating the offensive chances and the overall work rate. But the wheels came off in such an epic fashion that whatever good they did do was pretty well nullified.
The Stars have two days off to lick their wounds before limping into the all-star break with a game against the Anaheim Ducks.
More on this game after the jump.
- This game is hard for me to wrap my head around because in many ways, it's much better than what the team threw out there against the Tampa Bay Lightning. The players were mentally checked in from the puck drop, they created some pretty solid chances and they generally dictated most of the early part of the game. But when it all came apart, boy did it come apart in spectacular fashion.
- So what does that show? Well, that's open for interpretation at the point. But I do think the composure of the group has to face some pretty serious questions. It's one thing to allow one and even two goals, especially when one is a flukey tip off of a guy attempting to make a good defensive play. But the way they just got running around after the goals is pretty unacceptable and needs to change immediately. It's not just one player or four or five of them. Someone, somehow has to step up and take control of the team mentally to keep this from happening again.
- Only a few players escaped this game without a minus - Stephane Robidas, Radek Dvorak, Eric Nystrom, Steve Ott and Sheldon Souray were all even while Adam Burish and Vernon Fiddler were the only players to finish the game +1. Two guys finished at -2 - Tom Wandell and Michael Ryder, who were both out there fourth pretty backbreaking goal by Brodziak. The only players not out there for any Minnesota goal were Ott, Burish and Fiddler.
- Speaking of Nystrom, one of the positives in this game was seeing him score his 14th goal of the season against his former team. It was a beautiful tip on a Robidas shot, something the Stars basically repeated with the Larsen goal. Big props to the young Dane for his first career NHL goal. May it be the first of many.
- As for the defensive side of defense tonight, Larsen included? Not so hot. Most of the Wild goals were the direct result of defensive breakdowns, whether that was someone trying to fly the zone too early before possession was secure or making an ill-advised pinch. With the offense as anemic as it has been since Jamie Benn and Mike Ribeiro went down, the Stars can't afford to be making poor decisions like that.
- There's been a lot of discussion about heart, grit and whatnot, but tonight's game to me was about talent and the decided lack thereof on the offensive end without the top two centers. Now, one can absolutely make an argument the Wild are just as riddled with injuries. But I like the Wild's top wingers ability to create on their own more than the motley crew the Stars are throwing out there. Devin Setoguchi and Dany Heatley both made really solid plays tonight, and both scored goal-scorers goals. While I love Loui Eriksson, he's more of an all-around player than a dynamic offensive force, and Michael Ryder needs a good setup guy. Combine that with the Wild's supporting cast being more effective at creating offense on Saturday, and you have this game if you throw in a side helping of complete defensive failure for one minute.
- It also reiterates to me just how bad an idea it would be to shop someone like Mike Ribeiro. Wandell has done an admirable job of trying to fill in, but this team desperately, desperately needs players with puck poise and playmaking ability on the top two lines. Hopefully both should be back either for or right after the Anaheim game. It can't happen soon enough.
- The numbers won't look good for either of the goalies tonight, but neither had much help. Kari Lehtonen was hung out to dry repeatedly, and he made some solid saves before the Wild's offensive outburst. Richard Bachman was fine in relief.
- And again, I don't think this game is as bad as Friday's. It might make me angrier because of how it went down, but I think there is at least more to build on. I am a little sad that's what it's come down to, though.
- So how do you fix the Stars? I don't think it's nearly as straightforward as trading all the veterans, especially given many have no-trade clauses. But things are getting too concerning to just wait for the team's centers to return to full health. That's why they pay Joe Nieuwendyk and Glen Gulutzan the big bucks.
41 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Don't really know what to say.
Or all the words are material not for kids.
Trevor Daley is my cup of tea.
I'd have to agree with that
Texas Rangers - back-to-back American League Champions
TracyJean1972: YouTube channel
@TracyJean: Twitter account
I feel the same way
Everything that can be said about what’s wrong with this team has already said.
by PrussianBlue on Jan 21, 2012 10:48 PM CST up reply actions
How bout "Rasafrackin?"

"He punched the highlights out of her hair.... He punched the HIGHLIGHTS out of her hair!!!" -- Young Neil
by Tsudbury on Jan 21, 2012 10:48 PM CST up reply actions 2 recs
Go Muttley.
Gotta cheer for someone.
Trevor Daley is my cup of tea.
by Henri Muroke on Jan 21, 2012 10:52 PM CST up reply actions
All i feel now is complete apathy
but it’s got anger and hate bubbling underneath and it’s keeping me awake. Which isn’t great at 4.50 AM. Hope they are getting read the riot act
6.50 here.
I will be sleeping while this country shall perhaps have a new president.
Trevor Daley is my cup of tea.
by Henri Muroke on Jan 21, 2012 10:53 PM CST up reply actions
Which means no sleep.
Trevor Daley is my cup of tea.
by Henri Muroke on Jan 21, 2012 10:53 PM CST up reply actions
As an olive branch
If you feel the need to write a ton of profanity, feel free to do it in the OT.
I’m not sure if there’s such thing as therapeutic type-ranting, but don’t let the anger boil up.
by DFWTrojanTuba on Jan 21, 2012 10:54 PM CST up reply actions
Not sure if I'm angry.
Just lost, like this team was today.
Trevor Daley is my cup of tea.
by Henri Muroke on Jan 21, 2012 10:56 PM CST up reply actions
I want to stay optimistic. I really do.
But it’s hard.
That just sucked.
plenty of reasons to stay optimistic...
I brush up on the magic number and projections after tuesday.
"He punched the highlights out of her hair.... He punched the HIGHLIGHTS out of her hair!!!" -- Young Neil
Aside from the fact that they get outshot every game and have a growing negative goal differential
Defending Big D Check it out
Twitter
"You guys are talking about living forever like it’s a real thing, but I bust out a man shoving his head into a vagina, and it’s srs time?"
--iorange555 8/23/2011
that was hard to watch.
real hard. i dislike Otter more and more every game.
vimeo.com/graylikethecolor | twitter: @grayisthecolor | instagram: _graylikethecolor_ | PSN: graylikethecolor
by graylikethecolor on Jan 21, 2012 10:59 PM CST reply actions
i would be far more upset at the defense tonight than Ott.
"He punched the highlights out of her hair.... He punched the HIGHLIGHTS out of her hair!!!" -- Young Neil
Ott was one of three players not on the ice for any of the Minnesota goals
I don’t see how he’s taking the blame for this one
Follow me on Twitter @ErinB_DBD
cuz of the fighting?
other than that, i don’t know either. Hell, at least he was showing some emotion IMO.
"He punched the highlights out of her hair.... He punched the HIGHLIGHTS out of her hair!!!" -- Young Neil
just let me know when his chirping is effective again.
vimeo.com/graylikethecolor | twitter: @grayisthecolor | instagram: _graylikethecolor_ | PSN: graylikethecolor
by graylikethecolor on Jan 21, 2012 11:11 PM CST up reply actions
agreed.
he at least appears to give a damn.
by Travis Drybread on Jan 21, 2012 11:33 PM CST up reply actions
Ott's "giving a damn" stunt...
…needs to get a lot smarter. When you are among the top six in a depleted team, you cannot fight a Darrel Powe. The trade-off doesn’t help us at all.
by Dallas_Stars74 on Jan 22, 2012 12:19 AM CST up reply actions
See, this is legitimate to me
Though there is also a case to be made that “the code” says he has to answer the bell every once in a while to not be a complete hack.
And regardless of the fight, the rest of the team has to not go completely into the tank for a full minute of epic badness. Heck, it was a draw/slight win for Ott in my eyes. It’s not like they should have lost any momentum from it.
Follow me on Twitter @ErinB_DBD
"The Code?"
Larsen scores at 11:03 and Ott ‘honors the code’ at 11:19. Was that really necessary? I know the team lost the game, but why give the opposition the boost when you’ve just taken the lead?
To clarify what I’m saying: http://starsblog.dallasnews.com/archives/2012/01/wild-credit-steve-ott-for-changing-game.html
by Dallas_Stars74 on Jan 22, 2012 1:16 AM CST up reply actions
I saw that article
I’m going to comment about it in the links post tomorrow, because while I agree the Wild could have built momentum from it, the Stars probably should have too. So I still think it’s unfair to pin the loss of momentum on Ott because the rest of the team had plenty of opportunity to get a boost from it as well.
Ott entered the fight as soon as he stepped out of the box because Mr. Wild didn’t feel like he’d gotten his fair fight in the first round of roughings. I can kind of understand that.
Follow me on Twitter @ErinB_DBD
"I can kind of understand that."
I understand Mr.Wild doing it, I don’t understand Mr. (Adorable) Star doing it. And I also don’t buy the “we should have gotten a boost from it as well” when you have a recently anointed top-six guy in the box for 5 minutes when he should be helping his already depleted squad with whatever limited skill-set he possesses. That’s why I expect him to play it SMART and pick his fights; just like Souray told Chris Stewart to “**** off” when the latter wanted a piece of him earlier this season. It’s not like Ott hasn’t denied fighting anyone before (after irking them), has he?
BTW, the Wild players are the ones crediting Ott for their win/our loss. Hard to argue against that.
by Dallas_Stars74 on Jan 22, 2012 1:52 AM CST up reply actions
Don't think he was the problem.
No love to him tonight, but that will have to do.
No hate either. The whole team just went down.
Trevor Daley is my cup of tea.
by Henri Muroke on Jan 21, 2012 11:11 PM CST up reply actions
Well tonight was an interesting game to say the least, also looked like a pretty interesting GDT from what I read
Watching this game, especially the 3rd period, I was glad I let all my anger out while shoveling snow earlier. It’s so frustrating to watch right now as they keep on failing to get anything out of these games against bad teams and teams they need to beat. And it doesn’t help when it seems like every other team is getting points every night.
by chris1989 on Jan 21, 2012 11:53 PM CST via mobile reply actions
Missed the game
"Goaltenders are 3 sandwiches shy of a picnic. From the moment primitive man lurched erect, he survived on the principle that when something hard and potentially lethal comes toward you at great velocity, get the hell out of it's path." - Jim Taylor
Thank God.
Excellent post, Erin. Your best writing.
"Goaltenders are 3 sandwiches shy of a picnic. From the moment primitive man lurched erect, he survived on the principle that when something hard and potentially lethal comes toward you at great velocity, get the hell out of it's path." - Jim Taylor
Can't wait for the reviews this week:
Where Robidas, Souray, Morrow, and Grossman are all given “Favorable” reviews based on past perceptions. These guys have been horrible all season, in Souray’s case since about 15 games in. They need to go.
Robidas,Souray,Grossman,Larson,Ryder,&WANDELL
The above mentioned players are a drag on this team. Where is the pride & passion?
Wandell blows as a center. Larson is a decent puck moving defense man but he is undersized & cannot play the pesky style of Stars hockey we need.
Whats up with Gully? Dude ultimately he is responsible! In a game against Clutterbuck and other hard hitting Wild players, how can you scratch Fistric? When can we check consistently as a team? Hard hitting, pesky, & smart Stars hockey…. remember those good ole days?
Wake up Stars or you WILL BE WOKE UP SOON BY BIG JOE !
This boring lack luster game of hockey is killing me!
by deerslayertx on Jan 22, 2012 10:24 AM CST up reply actions
Well that was painful
Not hole lot of positives to come from that bile of poo.
The collapse might mask what was until that point a decent effort, I thought going 2-1 up we might actually get a point. Then all hell breaks loose and the team decided not to bother playing for a minute.
I don’t think Ott was to blame, that a load of bull from their team trying to score mental points for future games. It’s hardly Otts fault that everyone went into meltdown for a minute. The defense has to take some of the blame, not sure what Robidas was doing on the Clutterbuck goal.
I have to question Gully a little as well. I know Larsen is a good puck mover, and I thought he had a decent game. But with the Wild struggling I expected a lot of hits from them, and to scratch Fistric?? I don’t know, I think Fistric has been good this year, despite his lack of scoring.
Not sure what the answer is, and imp fed up of people wanting to see the captain of this team traded. There are at least 15 players I would get rid of before I even contemplated trading Morrow. I think it’s a short sited view that trading him would mean an uptake in results.
Yeh mindless blind support
that’l save the day.
It would also make this blog redundant as there would be no discussion, close it down lads
Went to the watching party
for the game. Great atmosphere up until the soul-crushing minute.
On the plus side, I won a hat and Burish tshirt!
DIY: do it yourself hockey! - Razor
I honestly haven't watched the last few games because i just got back to school so i've been preoccupied
But this sucks. We need more than just shaking up the lines, gritting our teeth and moving forward for this team. I firmly believe a move needs to be made, and a somewhat big one at that
I really thought they were going to get some results.
The team looked like it responded to Gully’s rant … but then it went to hell in a handbasket.
I thought Severyns take that they look emotionally fragile was an interesting observation.

by 



























