Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: This Week In GIFs

Dallas Stars Sale & Bankruptcy: Details On The Purchase Plan & Bankruptcy Proceedings

Yesterday the Dallas Stars kicked off the final steps in completing the sale of the franchise when they filed for bankruptcy in Delaware. As we've stated for a while now, these bankruptcy proceedings are needed and have been planned far in advance in order to assure that all creditors are satisfied as part of the plan. Now that the filings are complete, we've been able to spend nearly every waking hour since yesterday afternoon going through these documents and determining just how much we didn't know.

In all, there aren't many surprises. We've known that Tom Gaglardi was the "Stalking Horse", a bid used to kick off the bankruptcy proceedings and expedite the sale. In short, once the bankruptcy proceedings are complete and there are no other qualified bids made, then Gaglardi will purchase the team in accordance the specifics procedures spelled out the purchase agreement.

Also, and this is explicitly stated in several places in the document, the purpose of this sale is to ensure the Dallas Stars stay in Dallas and that Tom Gaglardi is committed to this as well. It's in a legal document now.

The "Stalking Horse Purchase Agreement" and the bankruptcy filings of the team are all tied together. The documents explicitly state that the purpose of filing for bankruptcy was to facilitate the sale of the team to Gaglardi, as well as to open up the sale to any potential parties who could make a qualified bid on the team. If more than one bid is made, then the sale goes to auction -- whoever wins the auction will then purchase the team.

After the jump, we've broken down these documents as best as we can to include as much of the pertinent information as we can find. There are many, many documents to go through with lots of details -- but I believe I've done the best I can at breaking it all down and providing it as simply as I can.

Right now, here is the proposed timetable -- although this is all subject to court approval.

Hearing to consider bidding procedures -- September 22
Qualified Bid deadline -- October 22
Objection deadline -- October 25
Reply date (if any) - October 31
Auction date -- November 21
Combined hearing -- November 23

If you have any questions, do not hesitate to ask. Lots of legal information after the jump....

Star-divide

** The plan breaks down the timeline of the proceedings, saying that after discussion with the NHL and the debtor's senior secured lenders, the team finalized a purchase agreement with "Dallas Sports & Entertainment, LP, which is listed as the "Stalking Horse Asset Purchase Agreement".  

This provides for the sale of all assets to the Stalking Horse under the prepackaged plan and is only subject to higher and better offers in a bidding process -- subject to NHL approval of the bid and bidder.

** By far, the largest unsecured claim against the Dallas Stars is what appears to have been a $44 million loan from the NHL, given under CFV I LLC -- a listed affiliate of the NHL. If Tom Gaglardi's bid becomes the actual Asset Purchase Agreement, he will pay this claim in full, in cash, upon consummation of the sale.


** The Dallas Stars as a company are broken down into four groups: Dallas Stars, L.P. (a limited partnership out of Delaware), Dallas Arena LLC, Dallas Stars U.S. Holdings Comp. and StarCenters LLC. All are debtors as part of the bankruptcy filing.

** The filings provide a summary of the Prepackaged Plan, which details everything that we've been reporting on for the past year. The plan provides for the sale of all of the assets of the debtors which includes:

- The hockey team which is a part of the National Hockey League; the Dallas Stars.
- The interests in four ice arenas and related assets in the Dallas-Fort Worth area.
- Ownership interests by Dallas Arena, tied to two other companies, which own and lease the American Airlines    Center.

**The plan specifically states that that the purpose of the sale is "to allow for a transition in ownership of the NHL Stars, while ensuring that the team continues to play professional ice hockey at the AAC in Dallas.

** At the same time that a Chapter 11 filing was made, a motion was filed seeking approval of the Stalking Horse Asset Purchase Agreement, as well as approval of bidding procedures and the scheduling of all hearings.

** As expected, as part of this bidding procedures the team will market the Purchased Assets for any potential purchasers that meet all requirements of the court and have prior approval of the NHL.  If any potential purchaser  submits a bid that is higher or better than the Stalking Horse bid, an auction will be held if more than one qualified bid is made. 

** If Tom Gaglardi is outbid and does not purchase the team, he will receive $4 million as part of a "break up fee". This is what provided an obligation for Gaglardi to become the Stalking Horse Bid, since he'll receive payment should he be outbid.

** Here is where it gets tricky. For any interested party to make a qualified bid against Gaglardi and the Stalking Horse Purchase Agreement, they must meet these requirements:

- The bid must be at least $10 million greater than the total value of the Stalking Horse Asset Purchase Agreement.

- The bid must be made by an "Acceptable Potential Bidder", which means that they've met the approval of the NHL and have proven that they have the financial capability and corporate authority to make such a bid on the team.

- There is no "break-up fee" for qualified bidders. Only Gaglardi gets that honor.

- All bids must be made prior to the deadline and there must be more than one qualified bid for the sale to go to auction.

- If the sale does go to auction, each bid must be at least $5 million more than the bid proceeding it.

** Here are the most substantial unsecured claims against the Dallas Stars:

Creditor Nature of Claim Amount of Claim

CFV I LLC
Loan $51,691,783
Hockey Club
Contractual 
Obligation For 
Player Picked 
up on Waive
$2,000,000
Marc Crawford
Contract 
Termination 
Obligations
$1,101,654
Duncanville Community 
Group and Economic 
Development 
Corporation
Terminated 
Lease 
Settlement
$683,405
BWD Group LLC Insurance $550,410
Plano Sports Authority
Terminated 
Lease 
Settlement
$344,860
Bill Guerin
Deferred 
Compensation
$190,000

** There are all 15 players still owed money as part of "deferred signing bonuses": 

- John Klingberg
- Patrick Nemeth
- Brenden Dillon
- Tomas Vincour
- Scott Glennie
- Jack Campbell
- Tyler Beskorowany
- Philip Larsen
- Matt Fraser
- Mikhail Stefanovich
- Ondrej Roman
- Luke Gazdic
- Mathieu Tousignant
- Jace Coyle
- Hubert Labrie

** Finally, here's the details on the Stalking Horse Asset Purchase Agreement proposed b Tom Gaglardi:

- The sale makes note that the acquisition includes 50% interest in the American Airlines Center, and that Gaglardi is committed to keeping the Stars in Dallas.

- Negotiations between the Debtors (Dallas Stars) and Gaglardi concluded on September 1.

- The sale includes the Dallas Stars team, all assets and interests associated with the Dr Pepper StarCenters and the sublease of the AAC. 

- The sale price includes full payment of the loan to the NHL, of at least $50 million in cash, payment in cash to pay expenses and fees relaing to the sale process, incurring debt in an aggregate principle amount not to exceed $100 million for partial satisfaction of the major secured claim, as well as the assumption of certain assumed liabilities.

- Gaglardi was required to place $15 million of the purchase price in escrow prior to the filing.

*****

The sale price is listed at just over $266 million several times in the documents, but the details of the purchase agreement by Tom Gaglardi only spells out around $150 million or so. I'm guessing that the rest is made up of assumed debt associated with the creditors, as well as the value of the 50% share of the AAC. 

Gaglardi's bid to purchase the Dallas Stars is substantial and is one that has been preapproved by all of the lenders. He's paying off a substantial debt to the NHL immediately after the sale is complete and is taking on a good amount (66%) of the debt associated with the senior lenders, in this case likely to be Monarch. 

It's going to be hard for any potential party to outbid Gaglardi and they've set up this Stalking Horse agreement in such a way to make it hard for another bidder to not only make a serious push to outbid Gaglardi, but to satisfy all of the requirements of the prepackaged plan to be an Acceptable Potential Bid.

Comment 38 comments  |  1 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Guys....

Thank Brandon for pouring over these docs. We’ve all been looking and talking among ourselves but he did the lions share by far and is now permanently cross eyed as a result.

by Brad Gardner on Sep 16, 2011 11:06 AM CDT reply actions  

Although I've hated lawyers for years...

Gaglardi has obvouisly employed slow movers who command incredible fees, and seem to have the best interests of Gaglardi and we faithful fans at heart. It’s taken too long for our tastes, but apparently is a deal well done. To the lawyers, “Nice work, you arrogant bastards.”

Unidentified, but reliable sources have informed the Times Herald that a St. Petersburg, Florida retirement community is negotiating with the Hicks Sports Group for the purchase of the Dallas Stars. "I don't believe it. Dickie Dunn wrote that. It's gotta be true. That's fantastic!"

by WhoMe? on Sep 16, 2011 11:14 AM CDT reply actions  

I don't think thats fair at all

The reason it’s such a massive document is because of how much nonsense they had to get through because of Hicks Sports Group.

Defending Big D Check it out
Twitter
"You guys are talking about living forever like it’s a real thing, but I bust out a man shoving his head into a vagina, and it’s srs time?"
--iorange555 8/23/2011

by Josh Lile on Sep 16, 2011 11:25 AM CDT up reply actions  

Not to mention that it's 4 separate entities owned by the same entity.

and assigning debts and figuring out who of the hundreds of people get paid take a long, LONG time.

"I want to have Jamie Benn's babies. And you can quote me on that." - Brandon Worley

by Tsudbury on Sep 16, 2011 11:27 AM CDT up reply actions  

See grudging approval above.

I realize how difficult it is, but every lawyer expands work to take all available time and dollar.

Unidentified, but reliable sources have informed the Times Herald that a St. Petersburg, Florida retirement community is negotiating with the Hicks Sports Group for the purchase of the Dallas Stars. "I don't believe it. Dickie Dunn wrote that. It's gotta be true. That's fantastic!"

by WhoMe? on Sep 16, 2011 11:36 AM CDT up reply actions  

That's quite the blanket statement

And completely unfair in this case. There are too many factors that go into it to assume anything like that.

For instance..the auction process is going to take two months…that isn’t the lawyers fault. They have to go by the schedule as laid out by the court.

Defending Big D Check it out
Twitter
"You guys are talking about living forever like it’s a real thing, but I bust out a man shoving his head into a vagina, and it’s srs time?"
--iorange555 8/23/2011

by Josh Lile on Sep 16, 2011 11:43 AM CDT up reply actions  

I also want to say this:

All of this information is spread across about 20 documents. So if it seems overwhelming and a bit disjointed..that’s because it is.

by Brandon Worley on Sep 16, 2011 11:24 AM CDT reply actions   1 recs

Of eye crossing potential

Defending Big D Check it out
Twitter
"You guys are talking about living forever like it’s a real thing, but I bust out a man shoving his head into a vagina, and it’s srs time?"
--iorange555 8/23/2011

by Josh Lile on Sep 16, 2011 11:27 AM CDT up reply actions  

I wouldn't be surprised if the "certain assumed liabilities" includes the payroll transactions.

260 Million….

$100 in secured debt.
$60 in unsecured debt ($50 of which immediately goes to the NHL)
and… $100 million in built in losses?

"I want to have Jamie Benn's babies. And you can quote me on that." - Brandon Worley

by Tsudbury on Sep 16, 2011 11:26 AM CDT reply actions  

Right.

The $260 figure is about the “worth” of the purchase, not so much how much is being paid and assumed. Even then, that figure is only mentioned when discusssing the “break up fee” for Gaglardi.

by Brandon Worley on Sep 16, 2011 11:29 AM CDT up reply actions  

that's as best as I can figure if you're coming up $100M short.

It was talked about so many times in the last year — structuring future losses into the deal. That’s gotta be it.

It also brings the value of the Stars up to what everyone really thinks it’s worth, that $250-275 range.

Even if one person wants to outbid Gaglardi on this thing, I seriously doubt there will be TWO parties willing to go at least $276.

"I want to have Jamie Benn's babies. And you can quote me on that." - Brandon Worley

by Tsudbury on Sep 16, 2011 11:36 AM CDT up reply actions  

Here's where my confusion starts.q

It explicitly states that there has to be more than one qualified bid to force an auction. Does that include Gaglardi?

Or does that mean that Greenberg can’t force an auction on his own.

by Brandon Worley on Sep 16, 2011 11:38 AM CDT up reply actions  

This is also my question

And one I don’t really know how we’re going to answer at this point.

by Brad Gardner on Sep 16, 2011 11:40 AM CDT up reply actions  

I assume it means more than one qualified bid TOTAL

I would certainly think it would be in the best interest of the creditors to have an auction, even if there’s just two parties bidding. Of course it is.

The verbiage is just…confusing to us non-legal types.

by Brad Gardner on Sep 16, 2011 11:41 AM CDT up reply actions  

Two things...

Gagliardi would be considered a bidder, so yes. Gaglardi + 1.

And until all unsecured creditors are paid for it makes sense that any money from a second bid goes immediately to satisfy the unsecured debts, then as cash towards the purchase. Thus increasing the debt percentage.

Defending Big D Check it out
Twitter
"You guys are talking about living forever like it’s a real thing, but I bust out a man shoving his head into a vagina, and it’s srs time?"
--iorange555 8/23/2011

by Josh Lile on Sep 16, 2011 11:45 AM CDT up reply actions  

I don't know about Gagliardi counting as the second bidder.

It doesn’t seem like it would be in his interest to immediately say he’s willing to pay more. I interpret it as 2 other parties saying they are willing to pay at least $276.

"I want to have Jamie Benn's babies. And you can quote me on that." - Brandon Worley

by Tsudbury on Sep 16, 2011 11:59 AM CDT up reply actions  

He isn't saying that he's willing to pay more.

He’s saying that his bid to buy the team is worth 267 million dollars. That is the initial bid to buy the team. Now they’re saying “If anyone else wants to come forward to try to beat it….bring it on”.

Defending Big D Check it out
Twitter
"You guys are talking about living forever like it’s a real thing, but I bust out a man shoving his head into a vagina, and it’s srs time?"
--iorange555 8/23/2011

by Josh Lile on Sep 16, 2011 12:21 PM CDT up reply actions  

Yeah, it is called a "stalking horse BID"...

So you’re probably right.

"I want to have Jamie Benn's babies. And you can quote me on that." - Brandon Worley

by Tsudbury on Sep 16, 2011 12:26 PM CDT up reply actions  

Gaglardi is the one qualified bid.

Any additional “qualified” bid will force an auction. That bid needs to be $10mil higher. From that point in the auction each bid needs to be $5mil higher.

by 1paniolo on Sep 16, 2011 2:22 PM CDT up reply actions  

They really can not structure expected future losses

into the sales price like that. Now Gaglardi can, and I’m sure did, factor that into his total budget for the next few years and that influenced the amount he is willing to bid. But future losses cannot be recognized before the sale. The only items that can be recognized as liabilities are actual debts of the organization.

Now things like existing contracts with the players ARE liabilities, that in some cases extend years into the future. Now I’m sure there are some accepted ways of recognizing those liabilities, and they are different if valued as a going concern or as a liquidation. No doubt there was a fair amount of negotiation on how to value those assumed liabilities. I’m sure those are the kind of things that make up the balance of the $100mil.

But I can guarantee that say a projected $35mil operating loss for the 2011-2012 season is not part of the official price submitted to the bankruptcy court.

by 1paniolo on Sep 16, 2011 2:36 PM CDT up reply actions  

So if I read this right,

The Hicks’ boys will still be owner’s of the Texas Stars and Cedar Park Center? Nuts. Not that they’d do the same stuff as Sr., but what’s the saying, “Nut doesn’t fall far from the tree,” or something like that.

by Chubbs78750 on Sep 16, 2011 11:43 AM CDT reply actions  

It was set up that way...

They new the issues with Stars and Rangers were going to be a mess when they created the Texas Stars so they deliberately placed it in his sons names. Hicks Sports Marketing was already in trouble at the time and there was no sense throwing money at a company that was going to be foreclosed on.

Remember, the Texas Stars played their first season with out a franchise in the AHL. The AHL allowed them to play a year with the agreement that they had to acquire a franchise before the end of that season.

by loomisc on Sep 16, 2011 12:21 PM CDT up reply actions  

thank you guys!

For breaking all of this down. Let me say I’m very excited this is finally going down! Oh and happy first day of camp! It’s been a good week

go go goligoski

by DALLASSTARS7 on Sep 16, 2011 12:21 PM CDT via iPhone app reply actions  

GREAT WORK!

Thanks Brandon. Uber great info.

Question: If Gaglardi assumes a substantial amount of the debt in the purchase price, is that a bad sign as far as his new ownership having funds to boost marketing, increase spend on salaries, etc. This of course also knowing that the next couple of years will likely generate further losses.

Waiting for the day GM Joe has a real budget

by Rizory on Sep 16, 2011 12:43 PM CDT reply actions  

This happened in the Rangers sale too

Defending Big D Check it out
Twitter
"You guys are talking about living forever like it’s a real thing, but I bust out a man shoving his head into a vagina, and it’s srs time?"
--iorange555 8/23/2011

by Josh Lile on Sep 16, 2011 12:45 PM CDT up reply actions  

Typically a certain amount of debt is assumed

to free up current cash for the things you mentioned. Of course the prior owners (lenders) try to get as much up front as possible. So your points are still valid. We just have to trust that Gaglardi has enough additional funds to build the franchise after taking over. The whole thing doesn’t make much sense unless he does though. It’s not like it is a positive cash flow generator as it sits.

by 1paniolo on Sep 16, 2011 2:28 PM CDT up reply actions  

November 23 is my birthday

Having the court process conclude and a new owner in place that day would be a nice birthday present.

Fabulous work, Brandon.

by cms1171 on Sep 16, 2011 12:59 PM CDT reply actions  

Thanks for breaking this down Brandon!

It’s so great being up to speed.

Heika suggests that the players were questioning decisions such as Woywitka over Mark Fistric --Brad Gardner

Maybe that's why Woywitka had that puzzled face after that goal....
"Shouldn’t Fistric have scored that?!" --Tsudbury

by EagleBelf on Sep 16, 2011 1:41 PM CDT reply actions  

This is good news !

looks out long nightmare is about to be over. Good work Brandon !

NO This is why i dont come here so much anymore. it has become a destination for certain types which i am not. Love the rangers, not this -- Mark from OC on Arrested Development

Except that Ron Washington says Face has been this team’s MVP.
So did Bobby Valentine, Evan Grant, Jon Heyman --Josey Wales

by shock00 on Sep 16, 2011 3:22 PM CDT reply actions  

our*

can’t type today

NO This is why i dont come here so much anymore. it has become a destination for certain types which i am not. Love the rangers, not this -- Mark from OC on Arrested Development

Except that Ron Washington says Face has been this team’s MVP.
So did Bobby Valentine, Evan Grant, Jon Heyman --Josey Wales

by shock00 on Sep 16, 2011 3:22 PM CDT up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to SB Nation's Dallas Stars website. We talk Stars hockey 24/7/365. You're welcome to join in the discussion; please follow the code of conduct for commentary.

Managing Editors

Brandon_small Brandon Worley

Sb_avatar_small Brad Gardner

Staff Writers

Twitterme_small Brandon Bibb

Hullring_small Cole Jones

100_0353_small Tsudbury

198849_alds_rangers_rays_baseball_small Josh Lile

Me2_small Taylor Baird

Erin_and_kevin_at_rangers_small Erin Bolen

317075_10150847392930195_672210194_21620161_1404425884_n_small Huw Wales

Contributors

Small starshorns

Pic_2011-02_small scm83x

Moderators

Avatar_small RyanM

Lolastros_small DFWTrojanTuba