DBD List-O-Matic: The 5 Most Hated Rivals
Before I begin, first I wanna say thanks for all the feedback and comments last week! As I mentioned last week, when it comes to sports, people see to love lists - this series was really only the result of seeing four or five episodes of NFL Network's "Top 10" program when the thought hit me: "Hey we should do something like this..." - So enjoy, and of course if you have any ideas for future top five lists feel free to suggest some in the comments or hit me up on Twitter!
Pretty much every team in the NHL has that one really hated rival. Back when the North Stars played in Minnesota, you could pretty much list off in the old Norris division as hated rivals - especially the Blackhawks and Blues. But ever since the Stars moved to Dallas, and then moved from one division to another, it can be argued that the Stars really don't have that one arch-nemesis type rival so many other NHL teams have.
So who are the Stars biggest rivals right now at the moment? Well...
#5 Most Hated: Los Angeles Kings
This one has seemingly only really picked up intensity after the lockout of 2005. Of course everyone remembers the crazy opening night game of the 05-06 season when the Stars came back from four goals down in the third period to win the game - a game that helped serve notice to the entire league that multiple goal leads were not completely safe any more like they had been - but since that game, the M.O. of these two teams when they get together seems to be "expect the unexpected and know that the game isn't really over until it's over."
The rest of the list, numbers four to one follow the jump...
#4 Most Hated: Colorado Avalanche
It is said that playoff series are the best way to form rivalries between teams and that is no more apparent than in terms of the Stars and Avalanche. No one will forget the epic 1999 and 2000 seven game series that both times saw the Stars earn spots in the Stanley Cup final and likewise the playoff defeats in 2004 and 2006 were as equally bitter. Sure, maybe in the late 90's and early 90's Avalanche fans had a bigger rivalry with Detroit, but Dallas ranked right up there and just like Detroit fans knew back then, it wasn't Avalanche but rather "Divealanche", "Foppa" was better known as "Floppa" and of course the one thing Stars fans had that Wings fans didn't even have... everyone knew "Eddie's Better."
#3 Most Hated: Detroit Red Wings
Speaking of Red Wings fans... what a smug bunch they are huh? Ya know, it's not so much that we hate the team - heck, it seems like former Stars become new Red Wings all the time (Hatcher... Verbeek... Hull... Mo?) - but man are Red Wings fans ever annoying or what? Anytime their team comes down to play at the AAC it seems like half the people attending came down from Detroit, they have the audacity to call themselves "Hockeytown, USA" and dang it their team always seems to win... a lot! It's not like the Stars beat the Red Wings much - especially in the playoffs - but when the Stars do beat them, it sure is a sweet feeling if for no other reason than to stick it back in the face of Wings fan right?
#2 Most Hated: San Jose Sharks
I've always had the feeling that Sharks fans hate the Stars more than we Stars fans hate the Sharks, but really can you blame us? I mean what have the Sharks ever really won right? Presidents trophy? Bah, Stars have one as well. Pacific division titles? We stopped counting after we had five. Conference championships? The Stars have four in their history. The one thing the Sharks do have the Stars beat in? Playoff choke jobs, but that's a narrow victory itself when you start think about it. Still save for the odd time that the Ducks spoiled the party, the Pacific division had always been a toss-up between the Stars and Sharks. Even though that battle doesn't happen now, the rivalry is still there.
#1 Most Hated: Anaheim Ducks
Everything we hate about the Sharks applies here of course but there is also the added bonus of the fact that the Ducks *have* accomplished almost just as much as the Stars including a Stanley Cup championship. Not to mention there are the playoff series in both 2003 where the Stars were clearly the better team on paper, yet stunned in a six game series loss and then in 2008 when the tables were turned and it was the Ducks who were upset by the Stars. But beyond all of that, doesn't it just seem like the Ducks have always iced a roster full of dirty players who make it their hobby to take cheap shots at our beloved heroes? From Ruslan Selei, Todd Ewen, Stu Grimson up to George Parros and Corey Perry, it sure seems like the Ducks have never had a shortage of players to really hate.
What do you think? Like the list as is? Would you rather add a team like the Edmonton Oilers or Vancouver Canucks into the list? Maybe you still hate the Hawks or Blues as an old-time North Stars fan? Have your say in the comments section!
0 recs |
47 comments
|
Comments
I'm indifferent to pretty much every team at this point.
Wings? They can go off a cliff
The Ducks win this contest though. I hate the city of Anaheim and wish nothing but misery on those Angels/Ducks fans.
were not fans of the stars either…hate the ugly uniforms…brett hull was a douche..robidias (mispell) darcy wakaluk (just kidding how can u hate someone with that name)..
hate the fact u dont belong in the “pacific” division..
hate the fact u kicked our asses more times than not…
yea a lot of hate…but in good fun
"People act funny around strange men with sticks."
-John Marston-
by SPADE-IN-VICTORHELL on Jul 26, 2010 1:30 PM CDT up reply actions
I don’t hate teams like LA, Detroit, and Phoenix. I just hate playing them. On the other hand, I loathe the Ducks. The only team I hate more than them is Pittsburgh.
As for the Sharks, I love playing against them. I’m glad we see them six times a year because the games are always so entertaining.
Here's to all us girls who love hockey...and the men who play it.
by Brad_Richards_Rocks on Jul 25, 2010 9:43 AM CDT via mobile reply actions
It has to be Anaheim
From that frustrating overtime loss and Jiggy on fire all the way back to that annoying movie, rediculous mascot and awful jerseys. Ok, maybe for a moment that angry wildwing cartoon logo had some appeal, but that duck foot as a “D” is pushing it too far. Remember that game years ago when, with about 2 minutes to go, a 45-minute Royal Rumble broke out? Brent Severyn chucking knuckles at Sydor – only to be teammates the next(?) year. Maybe it’s a blessing that so the away games are past my bedtime.
Edmonton doesn’t bother me much. They really support their team and they make nice ice and you know that they are playing for draft picks these days. They can always bring out Todd Marchant stories on you and ask how it felt to have your season end in a heartbeat. That sucked.
San Jose? I like how they are following in the footsteps of those President’s Trophy winners that fade during the playoffs. Who doesn’t love to hate Bryan Marchment, or how you could always count on Arturs Irbe to venture out of the crease to give up a goal just when you needed one?
Colorado? Much respect. Those series were awesome. Roy, Sakic, Foote, Forsberg… Clash of the Titans. Dropping everything in the middle of the afternoon to watch a playoff hockey game and realising that Mike Keane had some nifty moves.
Kings? I just find it frustrating how the season series have gone from heavily in our favor to theirs. The all blacks are pretty cool, but I’m still mad at them for ruining New Year’s Eve.
Phoenix was only fun when it was time to deal with Roenick and Tkachuk. Losing to Tipps teams is like rubbing salt.
Detriot can go pound sand. Take all that hockeytown, octopus, red army shtick and take a long walk. I don’t even want to pay the wings enough attention to hate them. Yeah, yeah, Stevie-Y and Gordie Howe, but I can’t stand it when Dallas turns red when they come to town.
Beating the Oilers is like....
Going to ChuckeCheese and beating all the kids at the games. FYI this is a great Sunday activity.
I am still "FRISKY FOR NISKY"
by RealDealNeal on Jul 25, 2010 1:20 PM CDT up reply actions
I wish that were allowed...
They don’t let you in unless you have a little kid now. I guess for the safety of the kids or whatever.
I’m not buying it. They just dont want me to win all the pizes with my skeeball tickets.
I’m surprised too the Oilers got as much attention as they did.. It feels like that rivalry has really faded.. not to mention I can tell you for sure that Oiler fans hate us a lot more than we hate them!
Still.. all it would take is a new playoff series between the two to spark hostilities.
Defending Big D: A Dallas Stars blog on SBN: easy to use, free to join.
@GameTimeArt: Offending and/or boring sports fans one tweet at a time!
by Art Middleton on Jul 25, 2010 10:33 PM CDT up reply actions
Oilers weren't a problem in 2000, but you can hate them for 1997.
Dunno. Other than that, it’s been fun to knock them out.
Hmmmm
I think it is harder to make this list because of not being in the playoffs for 2 seasons and having a shitty team.
1) San Jose-there is no team I love to see loose more than them
2) Anaheim
3) Detroit- anytime you loose to a team in the conference finals that team is gonna rise up on the list
4) Vancouver- Im biased because I live in BC, but I HATE the Canucks more than any other team in the NHL and lately they seem to have the Stars number and it pisses me off
5) Colorado/Edmonton- It’s a toss up and this is a nostalgia thing but old rivalries like this dont ever die they have just dwindled a bit…if we face them in the playoffs in the near future you will see it reignited in a hurry. You cannot play the same team in the playoffs over and over like we have these 2 teams and not acknowledge the rivalry.
1. San Jose
2. Detroit 3. Anaheim 4. Los Angeles 5. Phoenix
Colorado just has no one left from the old rivalry days (except Hejduk and Foote I guess), and the Stars-Avs games of the last several seasons have just not had that spark to them in my opinion. Ask me this question 5 or 6 years ago and Colorado might be no. 2 on the list. Edmonton hasn’t been on the radar since the pre-lockout days, but Stars-Oil games are admittedly still fun.
by disposablehero on Jul 25, 2010 12:37 PM CDT reply actions
I voted Detroit, but now that I think about it....
1. Duck, Duck, DIE.
2. Harpoon the Sharks.
3. Clip the Wings.
4. Off with the Kings’ heads.
5. Roadrunner > Coyote.
My 1 and 2 are close...
1. Detroit- A whole list of reasons…Red Wings fans and ‘08 Conference Finals is a start to the list.
2. San Jose- Close second. Love it when they lose, and love it more when they choke in the playoffs… especially since a good friend of mine is a Sharts fan.
3. Anaheim- Ok with the city, love the hockeygiant store down the street, but I hate the Ducks.
4.L.A.- Too many close, high scoring games with these guys in recent years…and their fans are some of the most classless people around(go figure its L.A. right?) and since I live in San Diego it’s natural to hate anything L.A.
5.Trashville I mean Nashville- I still hate Tootoo and the classless fans that follow them.
Nashville
I damn near had them in the top five.. I’ll never forget the night they disrespected Modano and hockey history.
Defending Big D: A Dallas Stars blog on SBN: easy to use, free to join.
@GameTimeArt: Offending and/or boring sports fans one tweet at a time!
by Art Middleton on Jul 25, 2010 10:34 PM CDT up reply actions
I have no love of Nashville
But putting them on the list would have been giving them more respect than they deserve.
by Brad Gardner on Jul 25, 2010 11:47 PM CDT up reply actions
I'm having trouble with this one.
This is difficult because the Stars haven’t been to the playoffs in 2 years. So the teams you hate are the ones you play the most, with the exception of Detroit. My list…
1. Red Wings, nostalgia? Opponents in one of the best stars playoff series in 08’. Also happens to be their last playoff appearence.
2. San Jose, because they are so good, and it feels good when Nisky beats them in the SO.
3. Anaheim, Bobby Ryan is a cock block.
4. Kings, because they are so good, and they have a whole new generation of “good” players to hate.
5. Pheonix, thank you James Neal. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xZzEOVZcz-s
I am still "FRISKY FOR NISKY"
Mine.
#1: Ducks
#2: Sharks
#3: Wings
#4: Wild
#5: Avalanche
Even though the LA Kings’ve gotten to be a good team these days, all I remember them as is the team that seemed to lose everything.
This list is hard for me because I have no particular emotions regarding most other NHL teams right now. Maybe that will change.
My list
1. San Jose – I get chills every time I think of October 24, 1998. That’s the night Bryan Marchment made his return to Dallas and 17,000+ at Reunion opened the game with a “Marchment Sucks” chant.
Obviously, San Jose fans didn’t have much love for Belfour. And even though both players hung up the skates long ago and neither roster has any single player that could considered polarizing, the rivalry still lives on.
2. Ducks – I openly loathe the city of Anaheim. Or at least their sports teams.
3. Kings – I don’t know how any Stars fan can’t have them on this list when you consider the number of strange losses that the Stars have suffered at the hands of the Kings at Staples Center.
4. Canucks – Just something about their fanbase that annoys the hell out of me. Granted, I shouldn’t hate them too much personally when you consider that my other team has made them their playoff bitch in each of the last two years.
5. Avalanche – I know the Stars had their playoff triumphs over them in the 90’s. But it’s those encounters in 2004 and 2006 that leave a bad taste in my mouth.
Especially in 2006. The Stars simply had no business losing in five games to those clowns.
I will forever hate Andrew Brunette for everything he ever did to the Stars in the postseason.
Still amazes me....
how something crazy seemingly always happens when the Stars visit the Kings at Staples Center
by disposablehero on Jul 25, 2010 3:12 PM CDT up reply actions
"Just something about their fanbase"
Exactly.
It has almost nothing to do with their actual team. (Though, there is an exception or two…But Luongo’s almost a bit at this point, so…)
by Brad Gardner on Jul 25, 2010 3:43 PM CDT up reply actions
I don't know
I’m not sure if I would hate them so much if I didn’t live on Vancouver Island. But I hate the fans and their fans hate the Stars. Luongo is just awful, he is a cocky head-case who should be able to carry that team way further than they ever get. LAst game in Vancouver some woman actually yelled at me to sit down for celebrating a Stars goal…..
I picked Detroit
because, well, their fans are almost as annoying as U of Michigan fans. muck fichigan
Proud fan of the #1 college hockey team in the nation - Miami University Redhawks - The Brotherhood. RIP Brendan Burke.
It depends...
The team’s top five rivals and my top five most hated are different.
Team’s top five:
1. San Jose
2. Anaheim
3. LA
4. Phoenix
5. Detroit
My top five most hated:
1. Detroit
2. Pittsburgh
3. Colorado
4. Anaheim
5. San Jose
1. Detroit
The fact that when their in town half of the AAC is red is enough to make me hate them. There is no other team I want the Stars to beat more every year than the Wings.
2. San Jose- A division rival, always seem to be really intense games when we play them. That epic series a couple years ago just helped the rivalry.
3. Anaheim- Read above next to San Joes.
4. St. Louis- The last couple years these teams act they don’t like each other. There always seems to be some sort of fight or injury that comes out of these games. And don’t forget the Blue’s fan whole “Kill Steve Ott” movement earlier in the year.
5. Maybe LA- They don’t really strike me as a team I hate, but the weird happenings in their building earns them the #5 spot.
Honorable Mention- Buffalo- Maybe not the team, but at least their fans. For one, that “Let’s Go Buffalo!” chant gets annoying. But mostly because for some reason their fans act like we went up there, stole their child, brought it back to Dallas, and then Guy Carbonneau threw it off of a second story balcony. Or something like that.
When reading quality hockey material isn't enough, The Black Green and Gold
Twitter @BlackGreenGold
That is such a great line!!
And if no one understands what the “child” is.. it sounds so wrong. lol
Buffalo fans I fans are harmless.. living in the shadow of Toronto AND New York and always coming close to winning but never quite making it.
Defending Big D: A Dallas Stars blog on SBN: easy to use, free to join.
@GameTimeArt: Offending and/or boring sports fans one tweet at a time!
by Art Middleton on Jul 25, 2010 10:37 PM CDT up reply actions
good stuff!
Anaheim, Detroit, and Colorado are the teams who are the most recent teams to really stand in the way of playoff progress for the Stars, besides themselves, and so its completely fitting that they are in there with the obvious choice of san jose, and LA is a growing one, but is a weak 5, but I can’t really think of a better one. I’d say solid list!
by Christopher Davis on Jul 25, 2010 11:15 PM CDT reply actions
Lets not forget...
First I voted for the Wings…I have to respect their organization, but I can still hate them.
However, I just want to throw in Nashville…maybe not as a ‘rival’ but as a team that I really dislike. From Tootoo’s sucker punch, to the fact that their “American” fans boo’ed when Modano hit 502 and 503. I understand opposing fans being upset they were scored upon, but they boo’ed all the more because of the record. The organization did nothing, the fans did nothing…there is no class in that town (hockey wise). Where as other places actually gave Mo the honor he deserved.
Wow I totally forgot about that
But I still hate them only because of Tootoo and their fans but I really respect Barry Trotz.
by Tyler Bouldin on Jul 26, 2010 2:11 AM CDT up reply actions
Compare that to us
When Roy broke the record for most minutes ever played (I think) some years ago. The guy got a standing ovation from the people in the arena, and Colorado was a MUCH bigger rival back then too. Love a team or hate ’em, we still recognize and honor greatness.
detroit – 98 conf finals and 08 conf finals, we have a solid collection of pres trohpys, div titles, but its about stanley cups and i firmly believe that in both of those years, the winner of the cup was coming out the west….to get so close and have it crushed and never know when you can get that far again, pisses me off like no other!! and if they get mikey mo, who is arguably, next to our cup win this franchises calling card it will piss me off even more (ill root for a mo hat trick and wings 4-3 loss for 82 games….)
Don't go putting words in my mouth now...
“it’s not so much that we hate the team”
No, I definitely hate the Wings as a team, mostly for their obnoxious Cup “win” where they cheated on pretty much every faceoff and dove and cried every time they were touched.
Except for Datsyuk- he’s actually a class act on a team of crybabies. Attention refs: You’re supposed to actually CALL interference once in a while. Yes, even on the Wings. That’s evidently what passes as “great” defense to them.
And I'm well aware
That the refs attempted for some strange reason to give makeup calls to the Pens about half way through that series. There’s not much in hockey I hate more than makeup calls.
Fact
I remember that night, might have been the one in October of 98, though I feel it was later, like 99 sometime…. we had a lot of calls of Maaaaarchmeeeent. I specifically remember him going to the penalty box in the third and the wave of calls washing over his slew footing, cheating hide.
Therefore, San Jose.
I hate Detroit, due to them beating us in 98 and I hate their bandwagonwheel fans. But San Jose and Marchment just trump all. If not for SJ dragging out our epic series, we would have rolled over Detroit I feel.
We need some more playoff success to breed some more life into our rivalries.
Get us back in the Central division, which I remember from when I started watching. I want more STL, DET, CHI games, less of the California crap teams. Get us a green jersey back ( I totally had a FanPost a few weeks before the main post about jerseys.. .though without the happy visuals:p ). Get us a new owner. And I think with those three things, we’re ready to roll all over folks again.
Along with a shutdown D-man or two, a PP QB, a righthanded face off whiz, and a for real goalie.
Yeah, those three things, plus those minor additions.
by Waywardstars on Jul 26, 2010 7:24 PM CDT up reply actions
Mine
5. Sharts
4. Sharts
3. Sharts
2. Sharts
1. Sharts
In that order. If they win six games in the season, I want them to all be against the sharts.
But beyond all of that, doesn’t it just seem like the Stars have always iced a roster full of dirty players who make it their hobby to take cheap shots at our beloved heroes?
Ummmm, I know you have Steve Ott, but I think you meant to say:
But beyond all of that, doesn’t it just seem like theStarsDUCKS have always iced a roster full of dirty players who make it their hobby to take cheap shots at our beloved heroes?
Do any other teams claim Dallas as the #1 Rival?, I know, that sucks. We’ll be yours guys, dont worry. But I’m afraid you dont rate as ours.
That's the problem...
We don’t really have one right now. Used to be the oilers, no problem. Then the Avs immediately after that. But it seems like since 2002 or so, we haven’t really ha da good rivalry. Ducks are good for now, yeah, but I wouldn’t call that anymore of a rivalry than your normal division competition.
Firstly, thanks for catching that typo.. Not sure how I missed it, but typing this at 1in the morning on a Saturday may have something to do with it.
As far as the Stars not being anyone’s #1, I think Stars fans are fine with that. The biggest reason the Stars don’t really rank as anyone’s top rival is the location issue.. The California teams obviously have the battle of California thing going on so even if the Stars happen to get into a bitter battle with one of them, there will still always been the battle of Cali to trump it. Same thing with the Oilers.. Sure Oiler fans hate the Stars, but it still doesn’t match the hatred that the battle of Alberta generates.
I think though as you can see through the comments and the poll, Anaheim isn’t everyone’s #1 most hated and may not even be in the top three…
That’s the great thing about making lists, the one I put up really is just my own with some consideration of what the general “population” feels… But everyone’s list can be different. And should say the Avalanche and Stars or the Oilers and Stars meet up in the playoffs in 2011 (quit your laughing everyone) then I think Edmonton would shoot back to everyone’s #1
Defending Big D: A Dallas Stars blog on SBN: easy to use, free to join.
@GameTimeArt: Offending and/or boring sports fans one tweet at a time!
by Art Middleton on Jul 27, 2010 10:18 AM CDT up reply actions
Maybe
Buffalo has us somewhere in their top 3 since they seem to have a sense of entitlement to the cup that we ‘stole’ from them :P….I swear, when I get to be 60 years old I get the feeling they’ll still be bitching about that.
by ibsurfer91932 on Jul 27, 2010 3:13 PM CDT up reply actions





















