Defending Big D: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
New Blog: Along The Olentangy for Ohio State Fans!

DBD List-O-Matic: Top 5 Stars Of All time

Welcome to what could possibly be a new fun series for us here on Defending Big D featuring top five lists.  Lets face it, everyone loves a good sports list!  People love making them, people love comparing them to others and people love complaining about them!  So every Sunday morning (if you dear readers are indeed game for it) we'll put out a new top five hockey list based on our own "expert" opinion (am I an expert?) but as always we'll leave the floor open to you fine people to agree, disagree, say we're out of our minds, whatever you choose and share your own personal list.

Today we tackle a list that at first I thought would be fairly easy to put together, but on further review it's not as cut and dry as one would expect...  The five greatest Stars of all-time.  Just so we're clear, we're talking Stars history covering from the Minnesota days of 1968 to 1993 and the Dallas Stars of now because quite honestly, the Stars franchise history is too deep and has too many great players to just simply ignore.

It's almost kind of painful to consider who was left off this list:  Dave Gagner, a three time Selke winner in Jere Lehtinen, hall of famers like Dino Ciccarelli and Brett Hull...  Still, when you look over the following five, it's hard to argue that they should be left off, although some of you just may!  Anyway, lets start off shall we?

#5 Greatest Star:  Ed Belfour

You can argue that Marty Turco is the Stars greatest goalie of all time and it was very tempting to put him at 5 over Eddie, but for me it came down to one question: If I was putting together a Stars all-time team to win one single game and the lineup was based on how they played while in their prime of their Stars career, who would I take?  Give me the guy that backstopped the team to a Stanley Cup please.

Numbers four through to one following the jump...

Star-divide

#4 Greatest Star: Sergei Zubov

Perhaps one of the NHL's most underrated defensemen of all-time, but there was no way "Zubie" was going to be left off this list.  Are Stars fans biased when extolling the virtues of #56 on the blue line?  Of course, but if we didn't do it, no one would!  Three time NHL all-star, named to the 2006 NHL post-season 2nd all-star team, a finalist for the Norris trophy in 2006 as well, although truth be told he should have been named a Norris finalist (and winner) more than just that one time 

#3 Greatest Star: Brian Bellows

Bellows carved himself a very nice career spending the first ten seasons of it with Minnesota.  In those ten seasons he never once scored less than 20 goals or had less than 50 points.  Bellows was for a short time in 1983-84 was the Stars captain at an age younger than Sidney Crosby and his leadership shined through again in 1991 when the Stars made their run to the Stanley Cup final as he led the North Stars playoff scoring with 29 points.

#2 Grestest Star: Neal Broten

It's a shame that Neal never got to win a Stanley Cup with the Stars franchise - even though he came close in both 1981 and 1991with the North Stars, because if he had the debate on who #1 would be much closer than anyone would probably admit to.  Still, Neal - who had his #7 retired by the Stars in 1998 - will always hold a prominent place in Stars history as he most likely will be on the team's statistical top five categories for some time to come.  Besides, even if somehow inexplicably long time North Stars fans forget about all the goals, points and clutch playoff play, they for sure will never forget the time Neal took Wayne Gretzky briefly out to the wood-shed.

#1 Grestest Star: Mike Modano

Ok, maybe we can all debate until the end of time on who should fill spots five through to two, but number one isn't up for debate at all right?  Eight time all-star, leads Stars in goals, assists, points and games played in both regular season and the playoffs.  Face of the franchise indeed.

What do you think?  Agree with the list?  Would put in a different order?  Make sure you let us know in the comments section!

0 recs  |  Comment 25 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

I Agree 100%

Although my knowledge of pre-1979 Stars players is very limited (based only on what I have read).

by GKrajci on Jul 18, 2010 9:07 AM CDT reply actions  

Excuse me for being biased toward the Dallas Stars because I was born in 1994, so I dint know a whole lot about the North Stars.

1. Mike Modano. Duh.

2. Sergei Zubov. Zubie was a special defenseman and never got the praise he deserved. He was truly one of a kind and is irreplaceable.

3. Neal Broten. I never got to see him play, but he must be pretty good if he has his number retired. Plus he was part of the Miracle on Ice, which is nice.

4. Jere Lehtinen. He didn’t get those three Selkes for just sitting around. He’s one of the beat defensive forwards to ever play hockey, in my opinion.

5. Derian Hatcher. Tough as nails, Derian always impressed me with his toughness. He did his job as a big bruiser (just ask Jeremy Roenick) and was vital to winning the Cup. Obviously he couldn’t play like that in the new NHL as easily, but at the time he was great at it.

Honorable mentions: Ed Belfour, Joe Nieuwendyk, Brett Hull, Marty Turco

Here's to all us girls who love hockey...and the men who play it.

by Brad_Richards_Rocks on Jul 18, 2010 10:01 AM CDT via mobile reply actions  

My favorite...

…was the one where Lehtonen gives him this awesome “WTF is wrong with you?” look.

by Sugaa on Jul 18, 2010 2:46 PM CDT up reply actions  

We have our #1!

But, like this list, there’s so many good options, it will be difficult to decide on 2-5

:-D

by Tsudbury on Jul 18, 2010 3:44 PM CDT up reply actions  

Good list

Obviously plenty of great players have played for the franchise, but it seems like many weren’t around for an extended period of time; at least not as long as the Top 4. I suppose one could argue Ciccarelli, but I’m not gonna pretend to have any knowledge of the dynamics of the 1980’s North Stars.

by Giant Space Ants on Jul 18, 2010 4:42 PM CDT reply actions  

Great List

Have to put Turco instead of Belfour – despite the championship – because of how he was as a teammate and what he did for the franchise off the ice. Also, Hatcher has to be on there; captain of the only stanley cup, phenomenal defenseman, and a home-grown product.

by Stars43 on Jul 18, 2010 5:16 PM CDT reply actions  

Hatcher was good..

But where do you put him? Don’t think you can put him over Zubov.. Maybe swap out Bellows, bump Zubov and Eddie/Marty ahead one and put in Hatcher at #5?

Defending Big D: A Dallas Stars blog on SBN: easy to use, free to join.
@GameTimeArt: Offending and/or boring sports fans one tweet at a time!

by Art Middleton on Jul 19, 2010 2:21 PM CDT up reply actions  

I never really paid attention to this team until they moved to Dallas

so from my limited expertise, my list would be
1. Modano
2. Broten
3. Zubov
4. Belfour
5. Lethinen
Then I’d prob go from a mix of Hatcher, Sydor, Nieuwy, and Morrow

by hinduplaya on Jul 18, 2010 5:23 PM CDT reply actions  

Just a thought for these lists

I like this list idea. I think you should make the lists based on the various trophies available. For instance, out of all the Stars players ever, who would win the Vezina, James Norris, Lady Bing, Conn Smythe (which player played the best for us in the playoffs), Calder (greatest rookie ever has to go to Brunnstrum, right?), etc. Just a thought. This list would obviously have been for the Hart Memorial trophy.

by whodafreak on Jul 19, 2010 11:00 AM CDT reply actions  

From a Minnesota fan's perspective

Mike Modano – Neal Broten – Dino Ciccarelli
Craig Hartsburg – Sergei Zubov
Gump Worsley

Proprietor of Hockey Wilderness - We take Minnesota hockey WAY too seriously.

by nathaneide on Jul 19, 2010 1:27 PM CDT reply actions  

Dude, I can't let this one slide by..

Gump?! I was gonna say there would be no way I’d put him over the likes of Cesar Maniago until I realized.. he was Maniago’s backup!

The other picks are good.. But Gump was a shell of his former self by the time he got to Minny.

Defending Big D: A Dallas Stars blog on SBN: easy to use, free to join.
@GameTimeArt: Offending and/or boring sports fans one tweet at a time!

by Art Middleton on Jul 19, 2010 2:18 PM CDT up reply actions  

Yeah

Maniago was clearly the best goalie in franchise history, bar none. But man … Gump freaking Worsley. I just can’t let it go.

Proprietor of Hockey Wilderness - We take Minnesota hockey WAY too seriously.

by nathaneide on Jul 19, 2010 3:48 PM CDT up reply actions  

1Jack Carlson
2Willie Plett
3Basil Mcrae
4Shane Churla
5Neal Brotten

by W1ldfan on Jul 19, 2010 1:52 PM CDT reply actions  

Hmm...

1. Modano
2. Zubov
3. Lehtinen
4. Broten
5. Bellows

It’s hard to not put Eddie here, but there goes.
Perhaps one day Ott will be here, but it will take time.

by Henri Muroke on Jul 19, 2010 2:28 PM CDT reply actions  

I think Ott will go down as one of the top five favorites...

but on an all-time list? Dunno about that. It’s mighty, mighty hard to crack a top five of Modano, Zubov, Broten, Belfour and Hatcher/Bellows.

by Pat Iversen on Jul 19, 2010 2:39 PM CDT up reply actions  

Oh

And Belfour should be nowhere near this list. Stupid Hawks.

And Secord Still Sucks.

Proprietor of Hockey Wilderness - We take Minnesota hockey WAY too seriously.

by nathaneide on Jul 19, 2010 3:49 PM CDT reply actions  

Agreed...

On the Secord thing anyway..

I had kinda debated the Belfour vs North Stars thing, but in the end the Cup was too big to ignore. If Hull had played a few more years, he’d be on this list despite the whole playing for the Blues and killing the Stars for years thing..

Defending Big D: A Dallas Stars blog on SBN: easy to use, free to join.
@GameTimeArt: Offending and/or boring sports fans one tweet at a time!

by Art Middleton on Jul 19, 2010 4:22 PM CDT up reply actions  

Ugh

Yeah, I definitely can’t put Hull on the list, and Dino was a necessity on there. Had a hard time leaving Goldsworthy off as well, but Modano and Broten can’t be moved.

I was torn between Goldsworthy and Bellows, but Dino was an enigma. Bobby Smith was another on the bubble, but he fell off too quickly and wasn’t around long enough.

Frankly, the hardest part was finding d-men. After Hartsburg, there wasn’t a lot of space for great Minnesota guys. Hatcher only played here one season, and frankly, Zubov was better even though he never played here. I suppose I could’ve gone with Curt Giles, but I was annoyed at the lack of solid defensemen in the North Stars ranks.

Proprietor of Hockey Wilderness - We take Minnesota hockey WAY too seriously.

by nathaneide on Jul 19, 2010 4:31 PM CDT up reply actions  

Heh, fair enough.

The reason why I said it ,is because it would be nice see new players on this list one day.

by Henri Muroke on Jul 19, 2010 3:50 PM CDT reply actions  

Modano is number one and Broten and Zubie have to be 2a and 2b....

For the rest you cant really go wrong with Belfour, Turcs, Lehts, Bellows, Ciccarelli, Dave Gagne(can’t believe he isn’t mentioned), Hatcher and I would even go so far as to say Ludwig(dont crucify me I love him).

"Success is never ending, failure is never final."

by GenericBrand on Jul 20, 2010 9:18 PM CDT reply actions  

My list

1. Modano
2. Belfour
3. Zubov
4. Broten
5. The duo of Hatcher and Matvichuk

Modano is a no brainer. Eddie because I’m a goalie myself and he’s been THE goalie I have tryed to learn from since the early 90’s. Zubie, the best D-man of he’s era. Broten also a no brainer on a list like this, maybe the position on it might be some other, but I put him on #4. Who could forget the pounding Derian and Richard put on Forsberg and the Avs, both in the -99 and 2000 playoffs (+any other time the Stars and Avs faced =] ).

Some players, who came close:
Lehtinen
Tinordi
Bellows
Churla
Ludwig
Moog
Turco

by Kyrpis on Jul 21, 2010 12:08 PM CDT reply actions  

Glad to see Eddie on the list

He was the backbone of the team during its most glorious episode.

by JoeyJoeJoeJr.Shabadoo on Jul 22, 2010 12:55 AM CDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to SB Nation's Dallas Stars website. We talk Stars hockey 24/7/365. You're welcome to join in the discussion; please follow the code of conduct for commentary.
Start posting about the Stars »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Osuhockey5_small
MAB v. Nisky
Bouldinstars_small
Breaking news: Mike Modano selected first overall in 2010 NHL Entry Draft
Bouldinstars_small
Would Bieksa be a good fit for Dallas?
2_small
Survey
Small
Why not Kaberle?
Txdpatch2_small
Welcome to Detroit, Mike. Have you met Ruslan?
Slideshow253_small
Willie Mitchell
Bouldinstars_small
It's now or never for Turco
Dsc04029_small
Is this it?
Loui-eriksson_small
Jersey three's part 2.

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

SBNation.com Recent Stories

PHILADELPHIA - MAY 16:  A fan of the Philadelphia Flyers holds up a sign reading "Next Goalie" behind goalie Carey Price #32 of the Montreal Canadiens in Game 1 of the Eastern Conference Finals during the 2010 NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs at Wachovia Center on May 16, 2010 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.  (Photo by Bruce Bennett/Getty Images)

Habs Finally Lock Up Carey Price, Sign Goalie To Two-Year Deal

National Hockey League commissioner Gary Bettman answers questions during a pre-game media availability before the Pittsburgh Penguins season opener against the New York Rangers in a NHL hockey game in Pittsburgh, Friday, Oct. 2, 2009. (AP Photo/Gene J. Puskar) +25 updates

Ultimatum? NHL Reportedly Threatens To Toss Out Kovalchuk, Luongo Deals Without NHLPA Concessions

Photo +1 updates

Report: Donald Fehr Hands NHLPA List Of Conditions On Becoming Union Leader

More from SBNation.com >


Managing Editors

Me8_small Brandon Worley

Sb_avatar_small Brad Gardner

Staff Writers

Twitterme_small Brandon Bibb

Avatar-body__1__small Art Middleton

Photo_on_2010-08-24_at_18 Pat Iversen

Don_small Mike Russo

AHL Correspondent

Gtalk_profile_small scm83x

Graphic Design Artist

Avatar_small RyanM