Defending Big D: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: MLB Trade Deadline: Astros' fans react to Oswalt trade

Winter Olympic Break: Grade The Dallas Stars Defensemen

ESPN Dallas is running a series that talks about several aspects of the Dallas Stars overall team this season, and whether they are trending up, down or about the average of what we expected for this season. He asked me to give my thoughts, and today we talked about the Dallas Stars forwards. You can read that here.

This got me to thinking about the expectations we've had for each player since the start of the season, and how those expectations have either been met or we've been left disappointed. We'll be grading each player for the complete season this summer, but with the Olympic break upon us I thought now would be a good time to talk about what our respective expectations might have been for each player. Today, we'll talk defensemen.

First, think about how you feel the defensemen have performed as a group over the season so far. Vote for the overall grade of blueliners and then stop by in the comments and let us know how you feel about each defensemen. Who has been the most improved? Who has disappointed the most? What needs to be done for this team group to take the next step?

After the jump, a quick rundown of each defensemen.

Star-divide

Remember: These grades are based upon expectations specific to that player.


GP G A P +/- PIM PPG SHG GWG GTG SOG PCT
2009 - Trevor Daley 56 3 9 12 -1 15 1 0 1 0 75 4.0

This was supposed to be Daley's breakout season, yet he has just 12 points and has scored nearly as many goals on Marty Turco as he has all season long. What's frustrating is we've seen Daley flash this great potential over and over again yet has never put it all together from game to game. Daley has certainly improved over the past month, and point production is not the only area where defensemen are graded; despite some major issues early on the past few weeks have seen a confident Trevor Daley truly step it up in his own zone.

Grade so far: C


GP G A P +/- PIM PPG SHG GWG GTG SOG PCT
2009 - Mark Fistric 48 1 7 8 15 43 0 0 0 0 31 3.2

Mark Fistric spent  a good portion of last season in the AHL, and he has returned to the NHL a changed hockey player. This is the big, strong, physical and nasty defensemen this team needs to counter it's offensive expectations and he's added some impressive defensive stability to go along with his hitting. Stars fans are excited about Fistric and his prospects moving forward, and it's been impressive to see how he's improved throughout the season.

Grade so far: A


GP G A P +/- PIM PPG SHG GWG GTG SOG PCT
2009 - Maxime Fortunus 8 0 0 0 -6 4 0 0 0 0 5 0.0

I'm including Fortunus here because it's looking like he may have a future in the NHL with this team, especially after the Ivan Vishnevskiy trade. He's become the go-to guy for when the Stars need a defensive call up on defense and while his numbers are far from impressive, he's certainly passed the eyeball test. He's a strong, intelligent defensemen who has been a good anchor when the Stars him.

Grade so far: B


GP G A P +/- PIM PPG SHG GWG GTG SOG PCT
2009 - Nicklas Grossman 54 0 4 4 0 24 0 0 0 0 47 0.0

There was time in the opening months of the season that Grossman led the entire NHL in plus/minus. Now, he's certainly come down to earth a bit as the season has progressed but Grossman has excelled playing next to Robidas all season long. I said last season that if Grossman can find a way to actually use his size to his advantage, then he'd be able to really turn the corner to becoming a top defenseman. Of the three young players on the blue line, he's come the farthest.

Grade so far: B


GP G A P +/- PIM PPG SHG GWG GTG SOG PCT
2009 - Matt Niskanen 57 2 10 12 -7 16 0 0 2 0 89 2.2

We all know his struggles, and it's tough to watch because it's obvious these are mental mistakes and nothing to really do with overall ability. He's earnest, has a big shot and great passing ability but he's suffering from a serious lack of confidence. He's improved lately, although he's still plagued by serious gaffes at the wrong time. Perhaps some time away from the power play, where he's struggled, could help his overall game.

Grade so far: D


GP G A P +/- PIM PPG SHG GWG GTG SOG PCT
2009 - Stephane Robidas 61 10 23 33 -6 37 7 0 1 0 142 7.0

He's Robidas. He takes a lick and he keeps going. He's slowed down significantly in offensive production the past few months, but he's holding up much better this season than last as the team's de facto number one guy.

Grade so far: A


GP G A P +/- PIM PPG SHG GWG GTG SOG PCT
2009 - Karlis Skrastins 59 2 9 11 -3 16 0 0 1 0 41 4.9

Skrastins has shown exactly what we expected he would be; a safe, intelligent defenseman who will block a ton of shots. He has influenced the team around him as well, as the Stars are blocking more shots overall than in previous seasons. He has just 16 penalty minutes, is rarely out of position and is just solid overall. He even has two goals!

Grade so far: B


GP G A P +/- PIM PPG SHG GWG GTG SOG PCT
2009 - Jeff Woywitka 25 0 3 3 -1 4 0 0 0 0 33 0.0

I've been impressed overall with Woywitka's play, as he's appeared in spot duty throughout the season. Because of injuries, he's played much more often lately than the first few months of the season and he's playing much stronger with better consistency in his efforts. Yet we still haven't seen the offense that was promised from his AHL days.

Grade so far: C

Poll
Dallas Stars defensemen so far based on your expectations?
A
2 votes
B
30 votes
C
109 votes
D
33 votes
F
3 votes

177 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs  |  Comment 14 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Good run down on each guy, I agree with basically everything. As much as defense has been a big issue with Fistric, Grossman, Robi going forward there is much to look forward to. A PP QB with size and a good shot is a must however. I love Robi…..but when he has twice as many points as any other blueliner, clearly, there are issues.

by brendan1 on Feb 17, 2010 8:36 PM CST reply actions  

Robidas

is a number 1 defensemen. we keep talking over and over about acquiring a number 1 defensemen, but how about a number 2. robidas’s stats (leads all defensemen in power play goals), minutes and the fact that he was invited to team canada’s tryouts all indicate that he’s a number one defensemen. hell, he was closer to making team canada than brad richards was, and no one is arguing that we need a number 1 center. it’s time that we truly appreciate how good stephane is.

by agvdstars on Feb 17, 2010 9:28 PM CST reply actions  

I think Robi is underrated by some Stars fans. The guy is steady, doesn’t get scored on, and makes plays. Not flashy, but hits, fast, all heart and team, and keeps the puck outta the net consistently. He handles his own on the top D pair.

by KStars on Feb 17, 2010 10:26 PM CST up reply actions  

I gave them a D

I expected much more out of Daley and Niskanen than I’ve seen.

by hiafex on Feb 18, 2010 12:47 AM CST reply actions  

If there were more choices...

I would have chosen either B- or C+, but instead I went with C.

by JCWM2 on Feb 18, 2010 1:49 AM CST reply actions  

I hate to point out the obvious...

But if we have 2 A’s and 3 B’s why does it feel like the defense is still so horrible?

I’ve brought this up before but I’m really curious about it: Does the coaching staff just not have them working on good defensive positioning?

Just about every team has been able to exploit their inability to vacate their zone and it seems to me to be a positional thing. Granted, I know squat about real hockey coaching but it seems like their defensive style doesn’t match their ability.

Do they go into the passive box generally when on the PK? Isn’t that meant to be a shot block-heavy defense? It just seems like they’ll block a shot and it’s quickly funneled back to the boards and back on net.

I know it’s a ton of work, but I’d personally like to see more tape analysis on their defensive style and whether or not it would be effective if they stuck to it.

by jabudi on Feb 18, 2010 8:50 AM CST reply actions  

And BTW

I don’t disagree with the grading…which is why it feels even more like a style issue.

by jabudi on Feb 18, 2010 8:50 AM CST up reply actions  

Based on expectations

I give them a C+/B- along the lines of Brandons individual grades above. Note that is NOT the grade I would give the defense … we are obviously a below average NHL defense. OK I won’t diss Robi … but we need a top pair guy from outside, lets call him a #2 ;^) That instantly moves everybody down a slot on what is expected from them and I really start to like the look of our D.

Of course that’s what I said last summer too … maybe I should have given the guys a B based on expectations.

by 1paniolo on Feb 18, 2010 1:14 PM CST reply actions  

Robidas elite

A+ for Robidas best defenseman in hockey! A for Fistric and Robidas for Norris Trophy. Leading Stars to Stanley Cup Victories.

by robidasmvp on Feb 18, 2010 2:23 PM CST reply actions  

I knew Robidas read Defending Big D

Defending Big D: A Dallas Stars blog on SBN: easy to use, free to join.

by Brandon Worley on Feb 18, 2010 3:32 PM CST up reply actions  

Robi.

This year doesn’t bear thinking about if we failed to reacquire Robidas in 05. We’ve talked about some dumb moves by the Armstrong administration, but giving Rubberdoll away for Klemm is really underrated for its overall stupidity.
When we gave him to the Hawks, I didn’t like the trade. I thought of him as a Bouncing Billy Bates, #3-#4 defenseman. I had zero prediction he would prove himself capable of soaking up #1 minutes and playing so well. But I did believe that you don’t trade away heart and soul players like Robi.
Imagine if Klemm was our #1 this year …

by Waywardstars on Feb 19, 2010 10:55 PM CST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to SB Nation's Dallas Stars website. We talk Stars hockey 24/7/365. You're welcome to join in the discussion; please follow the code of conduct for commentary.
Start posting about the Stars »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Loui-eriksson_small
Jersey three's part 2.
Loui-eriksson_small
Jersey Three's...An oldschool approach
Loui-eriksson_small
Jersey 2's
Loui-eriksson_small
Jersey one of five...AGAIN
Small
Otter Gets Some Love
Small
Lifetime Contracts
Loui-eriksson_small
Jersey one!
Small
Mark Cuban Cleared To Bid On Rangers
Small
Modano Update
100_0353_small
A few questions...

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

SBNation.com Recent Stories

NEWARK NJ - JULY 20:  Ilya Kovalchuk of the New Jersey Devils poses for photographs following the media opportunity announcing his contract renewal at the Prudential Center on July 20 2010 in Newark New Jersey.  (Photo by Bruce Bennett/Getty Images) +9 updates

With Arbitrator And Hearing Date Set, Is Kovalchuk Contract Mess Set To End?

In this photo taken on Monday, July 19, 2010, Atlanta Thrashers forward Andrew Ladd, formerly of the Stanley Cup champion Chicago Blackhawks, spends his day with the Stanley Cup atop Crown Mountain, British Columbia., north of Vancouver. Ladd, a two-time Stanley Cup champion, was flown by helicopter to the top of Crown Mountain to watch the sunrise. (AP Photo/The Canadian Press,  Mark L. Johnson) +55 updates

NHL Free Agency: Andrew Ladd Avoids Arbitration, Signs With Thrashers

FILE - In this May 7, 2009, file photo, Milan Michalek, front left, of the Czech Republic attacks Swedish goalie Jonas Gustavsson, right, during a quarterfinal at the Ice Hockey World Championship in Bern, Switzerland. Sweden's Carl Gunnarsson is seen behind on left. The Toronto Maple Leafs landed Gustavsson with a one-year contract on Tuesday, July 7, 2009. The 24-year-old netminder, nicknamed "The Monster," was also heavily pursued by Dallas, San Jose and Colorado. (AP Photo/Anja Niedringhaus, File) link

Euro Hockey For Dummies: A Primer On How European Hockey Leagues Work

More from SBNation.com >


Managing Editor

Sb_avatar_small Brad Gardner

Staff Writers

Twitterme_small Brandon Bibb

Avatar-body__1__small Art Middleton

39861_446847483435_675463435_6184793_6670288_n_small Pat Iversen

Don_small Mike Russo

AHL Correspondent

Gtalk_profile_small scm83x

Graphic Design Artist

Avatar_small RyanM