Defending Big D: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Around SBN: The Record of Wrongs: Vanderbilt Commodores

How accountable should Dave Tippett be for this past season?

For those of you who have asked, the Dallas Stars season retrospective will be presented in three parts starting this weekend.

101007tip250_mediumWith word coming down today the Edmonton Oilers had fired coach Craig McTavish, my thoughts immediately turned to Dave Tippett. The Stars missed the playoffs this season for just the third time in 16 years, yet there is some bitter disappointment inherent after a season that was supposed to be great turned disastrous fairly quickly.

For a team that struggles for relevance in a city with the Cowboys, Mavericks and even the Rangers, winning and winning consistently are the only ways to maintain interest in a hockey team in a football state. Despite the fact that the Stars are the classiest, hardest working, and most consistent team in the town (not to mention the only one to win a championship in the past 13 years), its not fair that this is the burden laid upon the organization but that is the reality of the situation.

So how much of the failures of this past season can be laid upon Dave Tippett's feet? The quick answer is to say none; the Stars had too many injuries to compete with healthier teams down the stretch. The team just lost too many key components and couldn't keep up the pace. But there certainly were some things Tippett could have done better.

The Stars power play was woeful all season long, ending up ranked 27th in the league. The team's inability to score on the power play was one of the primary causes of the big downfall in February and March. Sure, the team lost Sergei Zubov and Brad Richards but at times the power play units looked lost, disconnected and completely disjointed and not creative at all.

It falls on the coaching staff to adjust your strategies to fit the personnel on the ice, and this season it seemed as if the players were being forced into a system that wasn't working. Towards the end of the season, once the Stars had some players that actually fit into Tippett's system, the power play improved a bit but for a good seven weeks it was absolutely putrid.

The other issue was how Tippett handled the backup goaltending situation. The coaches and front office will say that Tobias Stephan had a bad training camp and didn't give any hints he was ready for 20 games as the backup. If that was the case, there were plenty of veteran netminders that became available throughout the season that could have done fine for one year.

And you can't tell me that having Tobias Stephan allowing 4-5 goals a game would have been any different that Marty Turco doing the same thing. Turco was overused in the middle of the season and when the team needed him most, he was too fatigued and worn down to give them the backbone they so desperately desired.

Yet despite these few misgiving I had about Tippett througout the season, I still believe he is the right person for the job. For now. He exemplifies the attitude and team atmosphere this franchise is known for, and isn't afraid to shake things up (sometimes) when things start going wrong.

The incredible amount of injuries this team had to endure this season most likely saved Tippett his job. Yet if the Stars falter again next season, expect a quick decision to be made to get things back on track. The Stars will be younger, faster and healthier next season; no excuses in 2009.

Poll
What decision should the Stars make this offseason concerning Dave Tippett?
Give him at least one more full season.
61 votes
Give him a short leash; bad start next year and he's gone.
32 votes
Do whatever it takes to get Guy Carbonneau behind the bench.
14 votes

107 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs  |  Comment 12 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

More from Defending Big D

Farewell Dave Tippett

Jun 2009 by Brandon Worley - 0 comments

Around SB Nation

Here come the Coyotes

Dec 2009 from From The Rink - 1 comment

Craig MacTavish - Future GM

Dec 2009 from The Copper & Blue - 25 comments

Comments

Display:

I don't see how much if anything this season is Tippett's fault

Is this the first year the team has not made it to the playoffs with Tippett as the coach?

by hiafex on Apr 15, 2009 6:04 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Yup.

But the Stars are held to a high standard, and unfortunately need to at least make the playoffs for the season to be deemed successful.

While the injuries were out of his control, we’ve seen other teams make it to the playoffs under similar circumstances. The St. Louis Blues have had just as many big injuries as the Stars, and fought their way back. They started playing inspired, disciplined hockey using the the players they had, but also got on the back of a very hot goalie. Of course, the Blues started their rise later in the season than the Stars did, so it could be argued they would have flamed out from exhaustion just like the Stars did.

But I’ve also seen two other teams, the Rangers and Penguins, hire new coaches and go from down and out to playing in the postseason.

Personally, I really like Dave Tippett and I think he’s perfect for this team. But I think he had just as down a year as everyone else did.

Defending Big D: A Dallas Stars blog on SBN: easy to use, free to join.

by Brandon Worley on Apr 15, 2009 6:26 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Agreed

The Blues rode their goalie to the playoffs and the Stars could not.

by hiafex on Apr 15, 2009 10:24 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Dave Tippet's future with Dallas

If the Dallas Stars start out poorly in the first 6 weeks
of next season then he should be replaced

by Robdentex on Apr 15, 2009 7:13 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

It was ten years ago!

I think it’s time we moved on from Guy Carbonneau.

by Patty (in Dallas) on Apr 15, 2009 8:42 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

I agree.

That was a bit of a……sarcastic……option.

Defending Big D: A Dallas Stars blog on SBN: easy to use, free to join.

by Brandon Worley on Apr 15, 2009 9:34 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

I know… I was mostly kidding, too. :D

by Patty (in Dallas) on Apr 16, 2009 12:18 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Preseason will tell all..

Start off bad in 2009 and Tipett, should start job hunting. The thing a lot of folks seem to be forgetting is, everybody was healthy at the beginning of this season … and boy did we have problems!!

I refuse to blame Avery for this …

The Stars will have no excuses next season!! Motto for 2009 – 2010.. MAKE IT HAPPEN!

by zombie on Apr 15, 2009 9:48 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

That's a great point.

Although, besides Avery, there was still a bit of turnover from last season.

Hagman, Miettinen, Zubov, Norstrom, Barnes…..all gone and replaced by young players, most making their NHL debuts (Neal and Brunnstrom). That’s tough. And they had a bad training camp, too, so the bad start wasn’t surprising.

Defending Big D: A Dallas Stars blog on SBN: easy to use, free to join.

by Brandon Worley on Apr 15, 2009 9:52 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

My views

I am totally AGAINST the firing of Dave Tippett. My reasons are as followed:

1) Nearly 400 games lost to players due to injuries. I would like to see any team out there try to replace your top forward (Morrow) who was lost in Nov., your top D-man lost in the same month (Zubov), your second best center (Richards) during the playoff hunt, one of our top wingers (Lehts) and countless other injuries, yet still be in the playoff hunt till the final month
2) The whole Avery thing. Now, we don’t know if Tippett was on board with this signing or not, but clearly Avery divided the locker room and hurt the chemistry all around. Tipps tried his best moving him around in the lineup and finding the best spot for him, but clearly it wasn’t going to work out
3) Turco. Now, I will bash Tipps here, cause the way Turco started the season out, he should have been benched for another goalie till he got his head straight, but Tipps didn’t have faith in our backups. Part of this could be the GMs fault, believing that this team should go ahead with a rookie goalie to backup Turco instead of a Vet. We all saw how this played out
4) Retirements. Clearly it could be seen that this team was hurt by the retirements of Barnes and Norstrom. Barnes was clearly a leader on this team and made a difference on the ice as a checking forward, so his lost hurts. Norstrom’s retirement came as a shock, as many around the organization believed that he would come back. His retirement towards the end of the free agency period left us little time to try and find a replacement (a Vet D-man), so we had to go into the season with a young Defensive line. Clearly his lost was felt on the D-line and Grossman
5) The players. Yes, I know that it is a coach’s job to coach up the players and get them ready to play, but the coach can’t go out their and play for them. The players have to take responsibility for their performance out on the ice. Still, both the players and the Coach could have worked together to perform better (especially on the Power Play)

Now, it is tough for us fans to see our team out of the playoffs, and usually the first to blame will be the coach. But remember, Tippett lead this team to the Conference Finals last year. We just ran into a ton of bad luck this year that took its toll on the team. Next year, though, with hopefully a full year of Morrow, the return(?) of Zubov and a healthy Lehts, a backup goalie, and another year for Neal, Brunnstorm and the young Defense men this team should get back in the hunt for the Cup

That's not hail you see in Frisco....that just Justin Smoak's Home Runs coming back into orbit....

by Smoak Some on Apr 16, 2009 12:10 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Plenty of reasons to dislike Tippet besides the two you mentioned.

Never once did he stand up and tell his team to suck it up and make the best with Avery. Modano, Turco and Robidas all bitched silently and made the locker room tense. The coach has to stand up and say enough is enough.

Completely mishandled Brunnstrom. Yes the guy was really, really bad in his own zone but playing forth line minutes with complete spares wasn’t going to improve his game. Benching him in favor of Conner, Begin, Barch, Wilson, Parrish, and Lundqvist was a travesty.

Sydor over Hutchinson for twenty plus games. It still blows my mind when I type that.

Personnel decisions on the power play besides just the system. Habitually throwing Robidas and then Modano on the point. Morrison there, but Daley wasn’t played on the powerplay. Grossman’s heavy shot was never given a chance. They were so bad for so long and it didn’t seem like Tippet was willing to try anything different. Oh and Neal on the 2nd unit, if he got any pp time early in the game at all, was just mind blowing. He was leading the team in pp goals, yet he still played second fiddle to Ott, Lehtinen, and Modano.

I could probably go on but seriously, he’s not the guy for this current roster. He’s defense first, which this team no longer is and completely unwilling to pull the plug on half effort from veterans.

by Hull Fan on Apr 16, 2009 4:05 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Never once did he stand up and tell his team to suck it up and make the best with Avery. Modano, Turco and Robidas all bitched silently and made the locker room tense. The coach has to stand up and say enough is enough.

I agree with so much. The one thing about Tippett I haven’t liked since he got here is he treats his players with kid gloves. Sometimes you just gotta get into a player’s face and tell them to shut up and sit down. He should have been riding the guys when they would sit around and watch a teammate get pummeled by an opposing team, no matter who it was. I’m just sick of him taking this team further and further down the wrong path. We used to have speed and power. They haven’t been playing the puck well and are just trying for easy goals, with a few notable exceptions. They just have no spark or fire, and it’s depressing.

by katya2032 on Apr 17, 2009 8:23 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to SB Nation's Dallas Stars website. We talk Stars hockey 24/7/365. You're welcome to join in the discussion; please follow the code of conduct for commentary.
Start posting about the Stars »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Kari Lehtonen
Profile_pic_small
**SPOILERS** LOST Ep 6.01 Discussion
Small
The Lost Season
Dos-xx-beer-baby_small
Time for Fistric to get his due?
Twitterme_small
Warren Peters Sent Down to Texas Stars
Profile_pic_small
LOST Season 6 Precursor Discussion Thread
Twitterme_small
Tom Wandell Out for Year
Belfour20_small
Falling Stars - What If The Stars Didn't Win The Cup?
Osuhockey5_small
So many leads...
Joeyavatar_small
Petr Sykora

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managing Editor

Profile_pic_small Brandon Worley

Staff Writers

Twitterme_small Brandon Bibb

Sb_avatar_small Brad G

Photo_10_small Derek B

Irbe_hockey_card_small Art_M

Don_small Mike Russo

AHL Correspondent

Gtalk_profile_small scm83x

Graphic Design Artist

Avatar_small RyanM