Defending Big D: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Around SBN: The Record of Wrongs: Vanderbilt Commodores

Dallas Stars are better off without Marty Turco? You can't be serious.

Mike Heika has an interesting post up this morning on his Dallas Morning News blog. Last night, Marty Turco and the Dallas Stars allowed the Los Angeles Kings to comeback from a 3-0 deficit, including two goals in the final three minutes of regulation. On his blog this morning, a lot of readers were angry not just with the Stars but Marty Turco in general. Heika talks about fans' frustrations and and concerns with Marty Turco's play and how some feel the Stars would be better off without him in the future.

Excuse me, what? The Dallas Stars would be a better team without Marty Turco?

Everyone calm down and let's discuss this rationally.

Star-divide

For a long time Marty Turco was known as a great regular season goaltender who was unable to perform in the playoffs. In fact, he played awful in the postseason and the Stars were unable to even come close to winning a playoff series. A couple of years ago there was a loud roar among the Stars faithful that the Dallas Stars should go in a different direction, trade Turco and find someone else who can just as easily lose in the playoffs for a much cheaper contract.

And then Turco put together a brilliant series against the Vancouver Canucks in 2007. He had three shutouts in that series, the only games the Stars would win. Then last season he continued his strong play with incredible performances against San Jose and Anaheim as the Stars won their first playoff series since 2003. The thought that Turco was no longer able to win in the playoffs became a thought of the past and there was high hopes for the Stars' postseason hopes in 2009.

This season has encapsulated everything that is great about Marty Turco, yet it has also magnified his shortcomings. The worst stretch of his career coincided with a horrible start for the team, with Turco fighting his mechanics and his confidence while allowing a highly abnormal amount of goals. Yet Turco was also able to turn things around for a month single handedly carried this team on his back with outstanding play while those in front of him started to struggle again.

There is no doubt that the Dallas Stars will only go as far as Marty Turco will take them this season. With the injuries they are dealing with this team will lean more heavily on Turco than have already had to so far this year. Yet some are afraid that his inconsistency at times will doom this team into not only missing out on the playoffs but failing miserably if they get that far. With that fear in their heads, a loud number of fans have now said the Stars should just move on without him. So is this just a knee-jerk reaction after a horrible loss last night or do people seriously think the Stars would be better off without one of the top goaltenders in the league?

Professional sports fans are tough to please. If you are losing then you must do everything possible to turn that around or risk losing your fan base. If you are winning, yet not winning it all than you aren't doing enough to make your team the best. Marty Turco and the Dallas Stars have been one of the most consistently successful teams in the NHL over the past decade, but because the Stars have not made it to the Stanley Cup Finals since 2000, then obviously this team is not doing enough to win.

Take a look around the league and look at how many teams would be thrilled to have a goaltender like Marty Turco in net for them every night. Finding a franchise goalie is the equivalent of finding a franchise quarterback in the NHL. It isn't easy and once you find one you stick with them as long as you think you can. It's not like the Stars can just trade Turco or let him go after next season when he's an unrestricted free agent and expect to have the same level of goaltending moving forward.

The Stars do have a young goaltender that scouts and coaches like: Richard Bachman at Colorado College. Are you ready as a fan to hand over the reins of the team to a goalie coming right out of college? Perhaps the Stars trade Turco and bring in a veteran to hold down the fort while Bachman gets experience in the AHL. Either way the Stars will be taking a temporary step backwards with Turco's departure and there's no guarantee that Bachman or whoever else will ever be as good as he was.

While Turco can be a maddening player to watch sometimes the good has always outweighed the bad. For every boneheaded goal he lets in like last night's at the end of regulation, he makes ten incredible highlight reel saves that keeps the team in the game. Last night without Turco the Stars would have been down in the first period and almost assuredly losing in the third. When you have a goaltender that plays nearly every game you have to take the good with the bad. Not every goalie can be as consistent as Patrick Roy was.

Are the Stars a better team without Marty Turco? Not a chance in hell. But should the Stars start planning for life without him? Of course. There's a chance that he will ask for too much money next season and the Stars let him test free agency. But if that happens watch how quickly he gets snatched up by a team desperate for goaltending and more than willing to overpay a veteran goalie.

Now imagine the Dallas Stars being that team in two years.

0 recs  |  Comment 3 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

To be fair...

The Stars only blew a 3-2 lead, not a 4-1 lead. Granted…it was a 3-0 lead at one point, but thankfully they didn’t allow 4 straight goals. Minor point, I know, but it’s better for my soul to reiterate that. :)

The answer is definitely not to replace Turco after this season (OR before). Turks has, as you said, fought his mechanics and battled through a slump that was extremely long and uncharacteristic of his usual high standard of play. He’s an all-star caliber goaltender, and a hard worker. His work ethic is unsurpassed by any other netminder in this league, and he hates to lose. And, if you were to go with another goaltender – who would it be? It’s not like there are many goalies in the league that don’t have their share of problems too. Goalies go through slides sometimes…but they also ride streaks.

Now, that doesn’t mean the Stars don’t need to consider grooming a replacement for Turco. They had that man in Mike Smith, for a while, but Smitty has moved on and the Stars fan-base should too, in regards to that particular goalie. I think the netminder of the future for the Stars could very well be Matt Climie. He’s playing for the Idaho Steelheads this year, and has looked impressive several times at that level. He’s by no means ready for the NHL yet, but could see some time at the end of next season. This means the Stars should probably look towards free agency and consider bringing in someone if they plan to cut ties with Marty. Personally, I’d sign him to a 1-year extension and consider things at that time. I have a feeling the Stars could be looking back and feeling a lot better about Turks at that time.

Big D Hockey: A hockey blog covering the Dallas Stars and other Texas hockey

by Big D Hockey on Mar 6, 2009 11:13 AM CST reply actions   0 recs

Fixed the score issue.

And Matt Climie is definitely in the future of the Stars, but there’s no way you just put all your eggs in a basket with Climie or Bachman. It will be interesting to see where they go in net in about two years.

Defending Big D: A Dallas Stars blog on SBN: easy to use, free to join.

by Brandon Worley on Mar 6, 2009 11:26 AM CST up reply actions   0 recs

If we can have a Franchise Player...

then why not have a franchise Goalie? Mo(dano) is already the Franchise Player (not that he needs the tag to be given to him by the team because its a no brainer to the fans that he is already anyways) So why not make the same case for Turco to be the Franchise Goalie? Might as well keep him here considering the alternatives and other options are too risky to even fathom and would only cost the team, as well as its fans, more money down the line anyways. Ignore the "Bandwagon Fans of the Dallas Stars and keep #35 between the pipes till he retires…

…then we can start worrying :D

.. and thats all i have to say about that.

by wthj77 on Mar 7, 2009 2:17 AM CST reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to SB Nation's Dallas Stars website. We talk Stars hockey 24/7/365. You're welcome to join in the discussion; please follow the code of conduct for commentary.
Start posting about the Stars »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Kari Lehtonen
Profile_pic_small
**SPOILERS** LOST Ep 6.01 Discussion
Small
The Lost Season
Dos-xx-beer-baby_small
Time for Fistric to get his due?
Twitterme_small
Warren Peters Sent Down to Texas Stars
Profile_pic_small
LOST Season 6 Precursor Discussion Thread
Twitterme_small
Tom Wandell Out for Year
Belfour20_small
Falling Stars - What If The Stars Didn't Win The Cup?
Osuhockey5_small
So many leads...
The_brotherhood_mourns_small
Petr Sykora

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managing Editor

Profile_pic_small Brandon Worley

Staff Writers

Twitterme_small Brandon Bibb

Sb_avatar_small Brad G

Photo_10_small Derek B

Irbe_hockey_card_small Art_M

Don_small Mike Russo

AHL Correspondent

Gtalk_profile_small scm83x

Graphic Design Artist

Avatar_small RyanM